A.K. Kraipak v. Union of India (1969)
Supreme Court of India · (1969) 2 SCC 262 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
Constitution Bench ruling establishing that principles of natural justice apply to administrative inquiries as well as quasi-judicial proceedings. The dividing line between administrative power and quasi-judicial power is thin and being obliterated. A selection board member who is himself an eligible competing candidate cannot participate in deliberations (nemo judex in causa sua).
Facts
- The Union of India constituted a Special Selection Board under the Indian Forest Service (Initial Recruitment) Regulations, 1966, for selecting officers from the Jammu & Kashmir State Forest Service into the newly constituted Indian Forest Service.
- The Selection Board included the Acting Chief Conservator of Forests of J&K, Naqushbund, who was himself an aspirant and eligible candidate competing for selection to the senior post in the IFS hierarchy.
- Although Naqushbund did not formally sit on the board when his own specific candidature was discussed, he participated in deliberations when candidates senior to him or rival contenders (including the petitioners, who were Conservators of Forests) were interviewed, assessed, and ranked.
- Naqushbund was selected at the top of the list, whereas several senior and meritorious officers were either dropped or superseded.
- The aggrieved officers filed writ petitions under Article 32 contending that the selection process was vitiated by personal bias and violated the fundamental principles of natural justice.
Issues
- Whether the rules of natural justice apply strictly to administrative proceedings or are confined exclusively to judicial and quasi-judicial determinations.
- Whether the presence of a candidate on the selection board, even if he recused himself during his own evaluation, vitiated the entire selection by reason of reasonable likelihood of bias.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Application of natural justice to administrative proceedings
Hegde, J. observed that the aim of rules of natural justice is to secure justice and prevent miscarriage of justice. These rules operate in areas not covered by any valid law; they do not supplant the law but supplement it. The dividing line between an administrative power and a quasi-judicial power is quite thin and is being gradually obliterated. In a welfare State, administrative authorities possess vast powers affecting civil rights, and minimum procedural fairness must be observed.
Real likelihood of bias invalidating selections
The test of bias is not whether actual bias was proved, but whether a reasonable person would have a reasonable apprehension of bias. Naqushbund was interested in safeguarding his own position and superseding rivals. His presence on the board during interview and ranking of competitors inherently compromised the impartiality of the board.
Decision
Selection list quashed. The Supreme Court held that the dividing line between administrative and quasi-judicial powers is thin and rapidly disappearing. Natural justice applies to administrative proceedings affecting rights. Naqushbund was a judge in his own cause because his presence on the board created a real likelihood of bias against competitor candidates.
Ratio decidendi
The rules of natural justice apply to administrative inquiries as well as quasi-judicial proceedings. The dividing line between administrative power and quasi-judicial power is thin and is being gradually obliterated. If an administrative exercise of power affects civil rights or leads to civil consequences, minimum standards of fairness must be observed. The rule against bias (nemo judex in causa sua) vitiates any selection where a member of the selection committee is also an applicant or competitor.
Exam points
- Erased the rigid dichotomy between administrative and quasi-judicial functions in Indian administrative law.
- Established that natural justice applies to purely administrative proceedings.
- Key authority for the test of reasonable likelihood of bias under nemo judex in causa sua.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Administrative Law, Natural Justice, Bias, Nemo Judex, Article 14