All India Bank Employees Assn. v. National Industrial Tribunal (1962)
Supreme Court of India · 1962 AIR 171 · Constitution Bench (5 Judges)
Summary
Seminal 5-Judge Constitution Bench ruling on the scope of freedom of association under Article 19(1)(c). Held that the right to form associations or unions does not carry with it a concomitant fundamental right to strike, to declare a lockout, or to achieve every objective of the union through collective bargaining; restrictions on industrial strikes are governed by labor statutes and not by Article 19(4).
Facts
- Section 34A of the Banking Companies Act, 1949 provided that banking companies were not required to disclose confidential information regarding secret reserves and bad debts in industrial disputes before Tribunals, unless the Tribunal directed otherwise.
- The All India Bank Employees Association challenged the validity of Section 34A under Article 19(1)(c), contending that the right to form trade unions carried an inherent right to effective collective bargaining and access to all financial accounts.
- The Association further argued that the right to strike and enforce demands was a fundamental right flowing naturally from the right to form unions.
Issues
- Whether the fundamental right to form associations or unions under Article 19(1)(c) encompasses a concomitant fundamental right to strike and carry on collective bargaining.
- Whether Section 34A of the Banking Companies Act unconstitutionally abridged the freedom guaranteed under Article 19(1)(c).
Provisions involved
Reasoning
No concomitant fundamental right to strike
Ayyangar, J. held that Article 19(1)(c) extends only to the formation of associations or unions. It does not carry with it a concomitant or guaranteed fundamental right to strike or to achieve every object for which the union was formed. If every activity of an association were treated as a fundamental right, the state would be powerless to regulate strikes in essential services under Article 19(4).
Strikes are statutory rights subject to regulation
The right to strike is a creation of the Industrial Disputes Act, subject to statutory conditions and prohibitions. It is not an organic fundamental right under Part III of the Constitution.
Decision
Appeal dismissed. Section 34A of the Banking Companies Act upheld; held that there is no fundamental right to strike under Article 19(1)(c).
Ratio decidendi
The fundamental right to form associations or unions guaranteed under Article 19(1)(c) of the Constitution does not carry with it a concomitant fundamental right to strike, to declare a lockout, or to achieve the objects of the association through coercive methods. The right to strike is merely a statutory right governed by industrial legislation, and restrictions on strikes do not violate Article 19(1)(c).
Exam points
- Rejection of the concomitant rights theory under Article 19(1)(c).
- Legal status of the right to strike in India: statutory right, not a fundamental right.
- Scope of permissible restrictions on unions under Article 19(4).
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 19(1)(c), Article 19(4), Right to Strike, Trade Unions