Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (Election Commission Appointments) (2023)

Supreme Court of India · (2023) 6 SCC 161 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

Landmark 5-judge Constitution Bench ruling safeguarding the independence of the Election Commission of India. Held that until Parliament enacted a law under Article 324(2), the appointment of the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and Election Commissioners (ECs) shall be made by the President on the advice of a high-powered selection committee comprising the Prime Minister, the Leader of Opposition, and the Chief Justice of India.

Facts

  • Under Article 324(2) of the Constitution, the appointment of the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners was to be made by the President, "subject to the provisions of any law made in that behalf by Parliament".
  • For over seven decades, Parliament failed to enact any law governing appointments, leaving the executive in exclusive control of appointing election commissioners.
  • Public interest writ petitions were filed under Article 32 challenging the executive monopoly over appointments as destructive of election commission independence and democracy.

Issues

  • Whether the executive monopoly over appointments to the Election Commission of India under Article 324(2) violates democracy and the rule of law.
  • Whether the Supreme Court can fill the legislative vacuum by prescribing an independent selection committee until Parliament enacts a law.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Independence of the Election Commission is vital for democracy

K.M. Joseph, J. observed that a healthy democracy requires an Election Commission that is fiercely independent and insulated from the executive. A person beholden to the executive for his appointment cannot be expected to act with complete impartiality when supervising ruling party candidates. Free and fair elections are part of the basic structure.

Filling legislative void via selection committee

The framers used the words "subject to the provisions of any law made by Parliament" expecting Parliament to enact a selection statute. To maintain constitutional trust during legislative inaction, the Court directed that the appointment shall be made on the recommendation of a Committee consisting of the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition (or single largest opposition party), and the Chief Justice of India.

Decision

Writ petitions allowed. The 5-judge Constitution Bench instituted a tripartite selection committee (PM, Leader of Opposition, CJI) to select the CEC and ECs until Parliament enacted a law under Article 324(2).

Ratio decidendi

Free and fair elections are an indispensable component of democracy and part of the basic structure of the Constitution. An Election Commission submissive to the executive strikes at the root of democratic governance. Until Parliament enacts a law under Article 324(2), the selection of the CEC and ECs must be made by a neutral committee consisting of the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition, and the Chief Justice of India.

Exam points

  • Landmark Constitution Bench decision on Article 324(2) and independence of the Election Commission.
  • Instituted a selection committee including the CJI to fill the 73-year legislative vacuum.
  • Prompted the enactment of the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners Act, 2023.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 324, Election Commission, Democracy, Separation of Powers

All judgments