Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal (2020)

Supreme Court of India · (2020) 7 SCC 1 · 3-Judge Bench

Summary

The 3-Judge Bench authoritative ruling resolved the conflicts created by Shafhi Mohammad and reaffirmed Anvar P.V., holding that a Section 65B(4) certificate (now BSA Section 63) is an indispensable condition precedent for the admissibility of secondary electronic evidence. The Court clarified that the certificate is not required if the original device is produced, and trial courts have inherent powers under Section 91 CrPC and Section 165 Evidence Act to summon certificates before trial concludes.

Facts

  • In an election petition challenging an election to the Maharashtra Legislative Assembly, the High Court directed the Election Commission to produce CCTV footage and video recordings of the nomination filing.
  • The Election Commission produced CDs/VCDs containing the video files but failed to provide the requisite Section 65B certificate despite repeated court orders.
  • A division bench of the Supreme Court in Shafhi Mohammad (2018) had diluted Section 65B by holding that a party not in possession of the electronic device cannot be compelled to produce a certificate. The issue was referred to a larger bench.

Issues

  • Whether the certificate under Section 65B(4) is mandatory even when the party producing the electronic record is not in possession of the original device.
  • At what stage must the Section 65B certificate be produced in civil and criminal proceedings.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Reaffirmation of Anvar P.V. and Overruling of Shafhi Mohammad

Nariman, J. affirmed Anvar P.V. and overruled Shafhi Mohammad. The certificate under Section 65B(4) is an absolute mandatory condition precedent for the admissibility of electronic records by way of secondary evidence.

Distinction between primary and secondary electronic records

The Court clarified that if the original device itself (the computer, phone, or digital recorder on which the evidence was first created) is brought to court and played, no Section 65B certificate is required because it is primary evidence under Section 62.

Power of the court to summon certificates

Where a party cannot obtain a certificate because the device is held by an uncooperative third party, the trial court has power under Section 91 CrPC / Section 165 Evidence Act / Order 16 CPC to summon the certificate before trial concludes.

Decision

Shafhi Mohammad overruled; Anvar P.V. affirmed; procedural framework for summoning Section 65B certificates established.

Ratio decidendi

The requirement of a certificate under Section 65B(4) of the Evidence Act is mandatory for secondary electronic evidence, but the court may direct production of the certificate through its coercive summons powers at any time prior to the completion of trial.

Exam points

  • Explicitly overruled Shafhi Mohammad (2018).
  • Original electronic device does not need a Section 65B certificate.
  • Defective certificate can be cured before the conclusion of trial under Section 91 CrPC / Section 165 Evidence Act.
  • High-yield precedent for BSA Section 63 electronic evidence.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, BSA, Evidence Act 65B, BSA 63, Electronic Evidence, Certificate

All judgments