Ashok Hurra v. Bipin Zaveri (1997)

Supreme Court of India · (1997) 4 SCC 226 · 2-Judge Bench

Summary

Pivotal Supreme Court judgment addressing unilateral withdrawal of consent under Section 13B(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. Held that where a marriage has irretrievably broken down, the Supreme Court can invoke its plenary power under Article 142 of the Constitution to dissolve the dead marriage despite the unilateral withdrawal of consent by one spouse.

Facts

  • The parties married in 1970 and separated shortly thereafter in 1983.
  • In 1984, they jointly filed a petition for divorce by mutual consent under Section 13B of the Hindu Marriage Act.
  • Before the second motion under Section 13B(2) could be heard, the wife unilaterally filed an application withdrawing her consent.
  • The husband contended that the marriage had been completely dead for 14 years and that the withdrawal of consent was actuated by malice and harassment.

Issues

  • Can a spouse unilaterally withdraw consent after jointly filing a petition under Section 13B(1) HMA.
  • Can the Supreme Court grant a decree of divorce under Article 142 where the marriage has irretrievably broken down notwithstanding withdrawal of consent.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Limitation of regular family court vs Article 142 powers

Majmudar, J. observed that while a family court cannot grant a decree under Section 13B if one party revokes consent before the second motion, the Supreme Court is not fettered by ordinary procedural technicalities. Under Article 142, the Supreme Court can dissolve an irretrievably broken marriage to do complete justice.

Dissolution of an empty legal shell

Where the marriage is dead emotionally and practically and living apart has continued for over a decade without any possibility of reconciliation, keeping the formal knot alive amounts to cruelty to both parties.

Decision

Appeal allowed. Marriage dissolved by a decree of divorce under Article 142 of the Constitution, subject to payment of permanent alimony to the wife.

Ratio decidendi

Under Article 142 of the Constitution, the Supreme Court has the power to do complete justice by granting a decree of divorce to dissolve a marriage that has irretrievably broken down, even if one spouse has unilaterally withdrawn consent prior to the second motion under Section 13B(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act.

Exam points

  • Precursor to the 2023 Shilpa Sailesh Constitution Bench decision.
  • Exercise of Article 142 powers in irretrievably broken Hindu marriages.
  • Interplay between Section 13B(2) mutual consent and unilateral revocation.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Family Law, HMA Section 13B, Article 142, Mutual Consent, Divorce

All judgments