M.R. Balaji v. State of Mysore (1963)

Supreme Court of India · AIR 1963 SC 649 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

The Constitution Bench laid down foundational principles governing reservations under Article 15(4): backwardness must be both social and educational; caste cannot be the sole or dominant criterion for backwardness; and affirmative action reservations cannot exceed 50%, as special provisions cannot destroy the general guarantee of equality.

Facts

  • The State of Mysore issued an executive order reserving 68% of seats in medical and engineering colleges for Backward Classes, More Backward Classes, Scheduled Castes, and Scheduled Tribes.
  • Only 32% of seats were left open for general merit.
  • Meritorious students who were denied admission challenged the order as a fraud on constitutional power under Article 15(4).

Issues

  • Whether caste can be the sole basis for determining backwardness under Article 15(4).
  • Whether the classification into "Backward" and "More Backward" was permissible.
  • What is the constitutional ceiling on reservations under Article 15(4).

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Caste cannot be the sole test

The Court held that Article 15(4) uses "classes" and not "castes". While caste may be a relevant factor in Hindu society, it cannot be the sole or dominant test of backwardness; poverty, occupation, and place of habitation are equally relevant.

The 50% reservation ceiling

Article 15(4) is a special provision; it cannot be interpreted to swallow or destroy the general rule of equality under Article 15(1). Speaking generally and in broad terms, reservation must be less than 50%.

Decision

The Mysore Government order reserving 68% seats was struck down as unconstitutional.

Ratio decidendi

Affirmative action under Article 15(4) cannot exceed 50% in the aggregate, and classification of backwardness based solely on caste is invalid.

Exam points

  • Origin of the 50% ceiling rule on reservations in India.
  • Backwardness under Art. 15(4) must be both social AND educational.
  • Caste cannot be the sole or dominant determinant of backwardness.
  • Sub-classification into "Backward" and "More Backward" without objective criteria struck down.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Reservation, 50% Limit, Article 15(4)

All judgments