Bharat Aluminium Co. v. Kaiser Aluminium Technical Services Inc. (BALCO) (2012)
Supreme Court of India · (2012) 9 SCC 552 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
Historic 5-judge Constitution Bench precedent overruling Bhatia International. Held that Part I of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 applies exclusively to arbitrations seated in India. Indian courts have no jurisdiction under Part I (including Section 9 for interim relief) to intervene in arbitrations where the seat of arbitration is outside India, establishing the territoriality principle in Indian arbitration law.
Facts
- Bharat Aluminium Co. (BALCO) entered into an agreement with Kaiser Aluminium for supply of technology and equipment for its plant in India.
- The dispute resolution clause provided that any dispute shall be settled by arbitration in London under the Rules of the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC), governed by English law.
- When disputes arose, BALCO filed a suit before the District Court at Bilaspur and an application under Section 9 of the Arbitration Act seeking interim injunction against Kaiser.
- In Bhatia International (2002), a 3-judge bench had held that Part I of the Act applies even to foreign-seated arbitrations unless the parties expressly or impliedly excluded it.
- A 5-judge Constitution Bench was constituted in BALCO to reconsider the correctness of Bhatia International.
Issues
- Whether Part I of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 applies to arbitrations seated outside India.
- Whether Indian courts can grant interim relief under Section 9 of the Act in aid of an arbitration taking place outside India.
- What is the legal significance of the "seat of arbitration" under the 1996 Act.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Territoriality principle and Seat of Arbitration
Surinder Singh Nijjar, J. for the unanimous Constitution Bench held that the 1996 Act accepted the territoriality principle of the UNCITRAL Model Law. Section 2(2) is clear: Part I applies only when the seat of arbitration is in India. Once the seat is outside India, Part I is wholly excluded. Indian courts have no jurisdiction to entertain applications under Section 9 (interim relief) or Section 34 (setting aside) in foreign-seated arbitrations.
Overruling Bhatia International prospectively
Bhatia International (2002) and Venture Global (2008) were expressly overruled. To protect transactions executed in reliance on earlier law, the Court applied prospective overruling: BALCO applies only to arbitration agreements entered into after September 6, 2012.
Decision
Reference answered. Bhatia International overruled. Part I held inapplicable to foreign-seated arbitrations. BALCO application under Section 9 held not maintainable before Indian courts.
Ratio decidendi
The Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 has accepted the territorial criterion. A plain reading of Section 2(2) establishes that Part I applies only where the place of arbitration is in India. No suit for interim injunction or Section 9 application is maintainable in India in relation to an international commercial arbitration seated outside India. The supervisory jurisdiction belongs exclusively to the courts of the country where the arbitration is seated.
Exam points
- 5-judge Constitution Bench ruling establishing the "Seat" and territoriality principle in Indian arbitration.
- Expressly overruled Bhatia International (2002) and Venture Global (2008).
- Applied prospective overruling to agreements executed on or after September 6, 2012.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Arbitration, ADR, Seat of Arbitration, BALCO, Section 9, Part I