Commissioner of Income Tax, Bangalore v. B.C. Srinivasa Setty (1981)

Supreme Court of India · (1981) 2 SCC 460 · AIR 1981 SC 972 · Three-Judge Bench · 1981-02-19

Summary

The Supreme Court held, under the law then applicable, that self-generated goodwill of a newly commenced business could not be subjected to capital-gains tax where the statutory computation provisions could not operate because its cost of acquisition could not be determined. The charging and computation provisions were treated as an integrated code.

Facts

  • A registered partnership firm had generated goodwill in the course of business.
  • On dissolution, the goodwill was valued and transferred to a newly constituted partnership.
  • The Revenue sought to bring the transfer within the capital-gains charge under Section 45 of the Income Tax Act, 1961.
  • The Supreme Court considered whether the computation provisions could apply to self-generated goodwill whose acquisition cost could not be ascertained.

Issues

  • Whether self-generated goodwill of a newly commenced business fell within the then applicable capital-gains scheme.
  • Whether capital gains could be charged where the statutory computation of cost of acquisition could not be performed.
  • Whether the charging and computation provisions operate as an integrated code.

Provisions involved

  • Income-tax Act, 1961 — s. 45 — Capital gains
  • Income-tax Act, 1961 — s. 48 — Mode of computation
  • Income-tax Act, 1961 — s. 55 — Meaning of adjusted cost, cost of improvement and cost of acquisition

Reasoning

Goodwill

Self-generated goodwill arises from reputation and business connections and, in the circumstances considered, had no ascertainable historical acquisition cost.

Integrated code

The charging and computation provisions operate together. The charging provision cannot be applied in isolation where the statutory computation mechanism cannot operate.

Computation

Where the scheme requires a determinable acquisition cost and that cost cannot be ascertained for the asset in question, the capital-gains computation fails for the transfer under the law then in force.

Decision

The Supreme Court dismissed the Revenue appeals and held that the transfer of self-generated goodwill of the newly commenced business was not chargeable to capital-gains tax under the statutory scheme then applicable.

Ratio decidendi

The charging and computation provisions form an integrated code; where the prescribed computation cannot be made for self-generated goodwill because its acquisition cost is incapable of determination, the charge under Section 45 cannot operate in the circumstances considered.

Exam points

  • Remember the integrated-code principle linking charging and computation provisions.
  • The case concerned the statutory position before later legislative changes to goodwill.
  • Do not treat the historical holding as the current tax treatment of every form of goodwill.

Tags: income-tax, capital-gains, goodwill, computation

All judgments