Bhaurao Shankar Lokhande v. State of Maharashtra (1965)
Supreme Court of India · AIR 1965 SC 1564 · 3-Judge Bench
Summary
Foundational 3-judge bench ruling on the law of bigamy under Section 494 IPC (s. 82 BNS). Held that the word "marries" in Section 494 means solemnizing a marriage with valid essential customary or statutory rites and ceremonies (such as Saptapadi and Kanyadan). An incomplete ceremony does not constitute marriage in law and cannot sustain a conviction for bigamy.
Facts
- Bhaurao Shankar Lokhande married his first wife Indubai in 1956 according to Hindu rites and ceremonies.
- While Indubai was still living and the marriage subsisted, Bhaurao allegedly contracted a second marriage with Kamlabai in February 1962.
- Indubai filed a criminal complaint against Bhaurao and his relatives alleging bigamy under Section 494 IPC read with Section 114 IPC.
- The evidence produced at trial revealed that while some rituals (Gandharva form) were performed, essential customary ceremonies—specifically Saptapadi (seven steps before the sacred fire) and Kanyadan—were not performed.
- The trial court and the Sessions Court convicted the accused; the Bombay High Court dismissed their revision.
- The accused appealed to the Supreme Court.
Issues
- Whether a conviction under Section 494 IPC for bigamy can be sustained if the second marriage was not solemnized with the essential customary rites and ceremonies required by personal law.
- What is the meaning of the expression "marries" within the scheme of Section 494 of the Indian Penal Code.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Strict proof of marriage solemnization under Section 494 IPC
Mudholkar, J. held that the word "marries" in Section 494 IPC means marrying in accordance with law or solemnizing a marriage. A marriage is not solemnized unless it is celebrated with proper and essential ceremonies. Mere performance of some rites without complying with essential ceremonies does not create marriage.
Essentiality of Saptapadi and statutory ceremonies
Under Section 7(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, where rites include Saptapadi, the marriage becomes complete and binding only when the seventh step is taken before the sacred fire. If the alleged second marriage is defective in essential rites, it is not a marriage in law, and no conviction for bigamy can lie.
Decision
Appeals allowed and convictions set aside. The Supreme Court held that unless the second marriage is shown to have been validly solemnized in accordance with applicable customary rites or Section 7 of the Hindu Marriage Act, no offence under Section 494 IPC is committed.
Ratio decidendi
The word "marries" in Section 494 IPC means marrying in accordance with law or solemnizing a marriage. A marriage is not solemnized unless it is celebrated with the proper and essential ceremonies and in due form. Mere performance of certain peripheral rites without complying with the essential requirements recognized by law or custom (such as Saptapadi under Section 7(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act) does not create the legal relationship of husband and wife.
Exam points
- Establishes the strict requirement of proving essential ceremonies (Saptapadi) to secure a conviction under Section 494 IPC / s. 82 BNS.
- Distinguishes mere intention or cohabitation from legal solemnization of marriage.
- Standard question in LLB, AIBE, and Judicial Services examinations on criminal/family law interface.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, BNS, IPC, Family Law, Bigamy, Section 494, Marriage Ceremonies