Canara Bank v. Canara Sales Corporation (1987)
Supreme Court of India · (1987) 2 SCC 666 · 2-Judge Bench
Summary
The Supreme Court delivered the authoritative textbook ruling on the liability of banks regarding forged cheques. The Court held that a cheque bearing a forged signature of the customer is a complete nullity in law, conferring no mandate upon the bank to debit the customer’s account. The bank cannot invoke the doctrine of estoppel against the customer merely because the customer’s accountant was negligent in checking passbook entries, unless the customer deliberately misled the bank.
Facts
- Canara Sales Corporation maintained a current account with Canara Bank at Mangalore.
- Between 1957 and 1961, the company’s chief accountant fraudulently forged the signature of the managing director on 42 cheques, encashing Rs. 3,26,047 from the bank for his personal benefit.
- Upon discovering the fraud, the company sued the bank for recovery of the debited amounts.
- The bank resisted the suit, contending that it had acted in good faith, that the company was grossly negligent in not verifying pass sheets sent every month, and that the company was estopped from claiming compensation.
Issues
- Whether a bank is liable to refund money paid out on cheques bearing forged signatures of the account holder.
- Whether the failure of a bank customer to scrutinize monthly pass sheets and report discrepancies creates an estoppel barring recovery against the bank.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Forged cheque is a null and void mandate
Ray, J. held that the relationship between a banker and customer is that of debtor and creditor. The bank is bound to honour the customer’s mandate. Since a forged signature is no signature at all in the eye of law, there is no mandate. When the bank pays on a forged cheque, it pays out its own money and has no legal authority to debit the customer’s account.
Rejection of the Estoppel defense
The Court held that the customer owes only two duties to the bank: (1) duty to refrain from drawing cheques in a negligent manner that facilitates fraud, and (2) duty to inform the bank as soon as he discovers forgery. There is no legal duty on the customer to inspect passbooks and detect fraud. Failure to inspect pass sheets does not create an estoppel against the customer unless there is an express agreement to that effect.
Decision
Suit against the bank decreed; Canara Bank ordered to refund Rs. 3,26,047 with interest to the customer.
Ratio decidendi
Payment made on a cheque bearing a forged customer signature is made without authority and is a nullity; in the absence of an express contract, customer negligence in checking pass sheets does not estop the customer from recovering the money from the bank.
Exam points
- Leading Indian authority on banker-customer liability for forged cheques.
- Established that a forged cheque confers zero mandate on the bank.
- Customer failure to verify pass sheets does NOT create an estoppel in favour of the bank.
- Bank pays out its own money when honouring a forged cheque.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Banking Law, Forged Cheque, Contract, Estoppel, Canara Bank