Chairman, Railway Board v. Chandrima Das (2000)

Supreme Court of India · (2000) 2 SCC 465 · 2-Judge Bench

Summary

The Supreme Court delivered an epochal human-rights ruling establishing that the fundamental right to life and personal liberty guaranteed under Article 21 is available to foreign nationals and non-citizens within Indian territory. The Court upheld an award of Rs. 10 lakhs as compensation against the Central Government for the gang rape of a Bangladeshi national by railway employees in the Rail Yatri Niwas at Howrah Railway Station.

Facts

  • Smt. Hanuffa Khatun, a national of Bangladesh who entered India, was gang-raped by several employees of the Central Railway in a room at the Rail Yatri Niwas at Howrah Station, Kolkata.
  • Chandrima Das, a practicing advocate of the Calcutta High Court, filed a PIL under Article 226 seeking public law compensation for the victim and safety guidelines for passengers.
  • The High Court awarded Rs. 10 lakhs compensation to the victim, payable by the Central Railway.
  • The Railway Board appealed to the Supreme Court, contending that a foreign national cannot invoke fundamental rights under the Constitution, that a third-party advocate had no locus standi, and that the State was not vicariously liable for the criminal acts of its employees.

Issues

  • Whether fundamental rights under Article 21 extend to foreign nationals and non-citizens within the territory of India.
  • Whether the Central Government is vicariously liable to pay public law compensation under writ jurisdiction for rape committed by its employees in a government premises.
  • Whether a third-party advocate has locus standi to file a writ petition on behalf of a victim of sexual violence.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Article 21 applies to every "person", including foreign nationals

Saghir Ahmad, J. held that the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) and the Indian Constitution protect the right to life of all human beings. While certain rights like Article 19 are reserved only for "citizens", Article 21 uses the broad word "person". Foreign nationals are entitled to full protection of life, bodily integrity, and personal liberty under Article 21 while on Indian soil.

Vicarious liability for constitutional tort in public law

The Court held that the Railways breached their public law duty of care. Rape is a violent violation of human dignity. The State cannot escape liability for gross violations of Article 21 committed by its servants in a facility operated by the Railways; Rs. 10 lakhs compensation was just and proper.

Decision

High Court judgment affirmed; Railway Board directed to pay Rs. 10 lakhs compensation to the Bangladeshi victim.

Ratio decidendi

The constitutional protection of life and personal liberty under Article 21 extends to non-citizens and foreign nationals, and the State is liable in public law to pay compensation for violations of bodily integrity caused by its servants.

Exam points

  • Held Article 21 applies to foreign nationals as it uses the word "person".
  • Awarded Rs. 10 lakhs compensation against the Central Government for rape of a Bangladeshi national.
  • Affirmed maintainability of PIL filed by an advocate on behalf of an indigent foreign victim.
  • Rejection of sovereign immunity defense in constitutional tort.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Tort, Article 21, Foreign Nationals, Public Law Damages, Railways

All judgments