Manohar Lal Sharma v. Principal Secretary (Coal Allocation) (2014)
Supreme Court of India · (2014) 9 SCC 737 · 3-Judge Bench
Summary
Historic 3-judge bench decision declaring the allocation of 214 coal blocks between 1993 and 2010 through the administrative Screening Committee and Government Dispensation Route completely illegal, arbitrary, and non-transparent. Struck down the allocations under Article 14 for total lack of guidelines, and cancelled 204 out of 214 coal blocks with an environmental levy of Rs. 295 per metric tonne of coal mined.
Facts
- Between 1993 and 2010, the Central Government allocated 218 coal blocks to commercial companies and public sector undertakings through an administrative Screening Committee mechanism.
- The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) submitted a report highlighting financial windfalls to private companies without competitive bidding.
- PILs were filed in the Supreme Court under Article 32 by Manohar Lal Sharma and Common Cause alleging crony capitalism, illegality under the Coal Mines (Nationalisation) Act, 1973, and violation of Article 14.
Issues
- Whether the allocation of coal blocks through the Screening Committee route was legal and compliant with the Coal Mines (Nationalisation) Act, 1973.
- Whether the allocation process was arbitrary, non-transparent, and violative of Article 14.
- What relief should be granted regarding commercial investments already made in commissioned coal plants.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Complete arbitrariness and lack of transparency
Lodha, C.J. held that the Screening Committee functioned without any objective guidelines or comparative evaluation criteria. Minutes revealed no reasons why one applicant was preferred over dozens of competitors. The process was completely opaque, arbitrary, and violative of Article 14.
Illegality under Coal Mines Nationalisation Act
The allocations violated the substantive provisions of the Coal Mines (Nationalisation) Act, 1973, which prohibited private commercial mining. Even State Government joint ventures were unauthorized fronts for private profit.
Decision
Petitions allowed. 214 coal block allocations declared illegal and arbitrary. 204 coal blocks cancelled; operational mines granted 6 months transition subject to paying Rs. 295/metric tonne levy.
Ratio decidendi
Natural resources belong to the people and the State holds them as a trustee. The allocation of scarce national natural resources by an administrative Screening Committee without transparent guidelines, competitive criteria, or recorded reasons is arbitrary, unfair, and void under Article 14 of the Constitution.
Exam points
- Landmark decision cancelling 204 coal blocks allocated over 17 years.
- Application of Article 14 non-arbitrariness to natural resource allocations.
- Reaffirmation of the Public Trust Doctrine in mining concessions.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 14, Natural Resources, Coal Scam, Arbitrariness, Public Trust