Committee of Creditors of Essar Steel India Ltd. v. Satish Kumar Gupta (2020)

Supreme Court of India · (2020) 8 SCC 531 · 3-Judge Bench

Summary

Monumental 3-judge bench ruling establishing the supreme supremacy of the "commercial wisdom" of the Committee of Creditors (CoC) in approving insolvency resolution plans under the IBC. Striking down the NCLAT order enforcing equal treatment between secured and operational creditors, held that neither NCLT nor NCLAT can sit in appeal over the business judgment of the CoC.

Facts

  • Essar Steel India Ltd. underwent CIRP with claims exceeding Rs. 54,000 crore. ArcelorMittal submitted a resolution plan offering Rs. 42,000 crore.
  • The CoC approved the plan with over 92% majority, allocating substantially higher recoveries to secured financial creditors than to operational creditors.
  • The NCLAT modified the plan, ordering pro-rata parity between financial creditors and operational creditors.
  • The Committee of Creditors appealed to the Supreme Court against the NCLAT interference.

Issues

  • What is the scope of judicial review of NCLT and NCLAT over the commercial wisdom of the Committee of Creditors.
  • Can operational creditors demand absolute parity of payment with secured financial creditors in an IBC resolution plan.

Provisions involved

  • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 — s. Section 30(2) & Section 31 — Approval of resolution plan and primacy of Committee of Creditors

Reasoning

Sanctity of the commercial wisdom of the CoC

Nariman, J. held that the commercial wisdom of the CoC is non-justiciable. The adjudicating authority (NCLT) and appellate tribunal (NCLAT) have limited jurisdiction under Section 30(2) to ensure compliance with legal requirements, but cannot second-guess the commercial viability, feasibility, or distribution metrics decided by financial creditors.

Secured vs operational creditors equality rejected

Equality between unequals is unconstitutional. Secured financial creditors who took commercial credit risks cannot be treated on par with operational creditors.

Decision

Appeals allowed. NCLAT order setting aside CoC distribution reversed; ArcelorMittal resolution plan approved as passed by the CoC.

Ratio decidendi

Under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, the commercial wisdom of the Committee of Creditors in evaluating the feasibility, viability, and distribution of funds in a resolution plan is paramount. The NCLT and NCLAT have no jurisdiction to modify the commercial distribution or enforce equality between secured financial creditors and operational creditors.

Exam points

  • Establishes the supreme non-justiciable authority of the "commercial wisdom of CoC".
  • Limits judicial review by NCLT/NCLAT strictly to Section 30(2) parameters.
  • Secured financial creditors are not required to be treated on parity with operational creditors.

Tags: AIBE, Commercial Law, IBC, Essar Steel, CoC, NCLT, Resolution Plan

All judgments