Centre for Public Interest Litigation v. Union of India (2G Spectrum) (2012)
Supreme Court of India · (2012) 3 SCC 1 · 2-Judge Bench
Summary
Historic Supreme Court judgment cancelling 122 2G telecom licenses granted to private telecommunication operators by the Department of Telecommunications in 2008. Struck down the "First-Come-First-Served" (FCFS) policy for allocation of scarce natural resources as inherently arbitrary, flawed, and open to manipulation under Article 14, holding that public auction is the only transparent method for alienating finite public resources.
Facts
- In January 2008, the Department of Telecommunications under Minister A. Raja allocated 122 2G unified access service telecom licenses along with bundled 2G spectrum at 2001 entry fee prices.
- The Department advanced the cut-off date without prior notice, introduced a counter-window queue system, and awarded licenses on a "First-Come-First-Served" basis within hours to favored front companies.
- The CAG estimated massive presumptive revenue loss to the public exchequer.
- The Centre for Public Interest Litigation (CPIL) and Subramanian Swamy filed PILs under Article 32 seeking cancellation of the licenses and court-monitored CBI investigation.
Issues
- Whether the First-Come-First-Served policy applied for allocating 2G spectrum licenses was arbitrary and violative of Article 14.
- Whether the State is constitutionally bound to dispose of scarce economic natural resources only by public auction.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
First-Come-First-Served policy is inherently arbitrary
Singhvi, J. held that the First-Come-First-Served policy is inherently flawed and dangerous when applied to scarce commercial natural resources. It enables unscrupulous entities with inside information to queue first and hijack public assets. Changing cut-off dates retroactively was a blatant fraud on power.
Mandatory public auction for natural resources
Natural resources belong to the people. The State as a trustee is bound to distribute material resources transparently. The Court held that a public auction is the only fair and transparent method for the alienation of natural resources to ensure equal opportunity and fair value.
Decision
Writ petitions allowed. 122 telecom licenses cancelled. Central Government directed to allocate spectrum through open, transparent, and competitive public auction.
Ratio decidendi
Spectrum and electromagnetic airwaves are scarce, finite natural resources owned by the people in public trust. The allocation of such commercial natural resources on a "First-Come-First-Served" basis without transparent public bidding violates Article 14 of the Constitution. Alienation of scarce commercial resources must follow open and transparent competitive procedures.
Exam points
- Cancellation of 122 2G telecom licenses across India.
- Invalidation of the First-Come-First-Served method for natural resources.
- Triggered the landmark Presidential Reference in Special Reference No. 1 of 2012.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 14, 2G Spectrum, Public Trust, Auctions, Natural Resources