State of Maharashtra v. Damu (2000)
Supreme Court of India · (2000) 6 SCC 269 · 2-Judge Bench
Summary
Authoritative Supreme Court ruling on the interpretation of "discovery of fact" under Section 27 of the Evidence Act (now Section 23 BSA). Clarified that the "fact discovered" is not merely the physical object produced, but the place from which it is produced and the accused knowledge of that place.
Facts
- The accused were tried for the abduction, human sacrifice, and murder of young children in a village in Maharashtra.
- During investigation, accused Damu made a confessional disclosure statement to the police stating that the dead body of a victim child was thrown into a canal after being carried on a motorcycle.
- Pursuant to his information, the police recovered the mutilated dead body of the child from the canal bed.
- The High Court acquitted the accused on the ground that the disclosure statement was inadmissible confession to a police officer.
- The State appealed to the Supreme Court.
Issues
- What constitutes a "fact discovered" in consequence of information received from an accused under Section 27 Evidence Act.
- Whether discovery of a dead body at the instance of an accused can be linked with other circumstantial evidence to sustain conviction.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
The true meaning of "fact discovered"
K.T. Thomas, J. reaffirmed the Privy Council dictum in Pulukuri Kottaya: The "fact discovered" within the meaning of Section 27 is not the physical object alone. It embraces the place from which the object was produced and the accused knowledge of its concealment, which is confirmed by the physical recovery.
Chain of circumstantial evidence complete
The disclosure of the location where the dead body was submerged, coupled with bloodstains on the motorcycle matching the victim blood group, formed an unbreakable chain of circumstantial evidence leaving no doubt of guilt.
Decision
State appeal allowed. High Court acquittal reversed; conviction and life sentence under Section 302/201 IPC restored against accused.
Ratio decidendi
Under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act (Section 23 BSA), the "fact discovered" in consequence of information received from an accused in custody is not just the physical article recovered, but the location where it was hidden and the accused personal knowledge of that place, which is conclusively authenticated by the discovery.
Exam points
- Modern reaffirmation of Pulukuri Kottaya principles on Section 27 Evidence Act.
- Definition of "fact discovered" under Section 27 (Section 23 BSA).
- Interplay of disclosure statements with forensic corroboration.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Evidence, Section 27, BSA 23, Discovery, Circumstantial Evidence