Dasrath Rupsingh Rathod v. State of Maharashtra (2014)
Supreme Court of India · (2014) 9 SCC 129 · 3-Judge Bench
Summary
The 3-Judge Bench delivered a landmark ruling on the territorial jurisdiction of courts to entertain complaints under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. Overruling K. Bhaskaran (1999), the Court held that territorial jurisdiction is restricted solely to the court within whose local jurisdiction the drawee bank (where the drawer maintains the account) is situated. This decision prompted Parliament to enact the Negotiable Instruments (Amendment) Act, 2015, which statutorily established jurisdiction at the payee’s collecting bank branch.
Facts
- A cheque drawn on the Bank of Baroda branch at Nandurbar (Maharashtra) was dishonoured.
- The payee deposited the cheque in his bank at Panvel and filed a complaint under Section 138 NI Act before the Judicial Magistrate First Class at Panvel.
- Under the earlier 2-Judge Bench ruling in K. Bhaskaran (1999), a complaint could be filed at any of five places (issuance, presentation, dishonour, notice, or non-payment). Payees routinely selected courts far from the drawer to cause harassment.
- The Magistrate at Panvel returned the complaint for lack of territorial jurisdiction, leading to an appeal to the Supreme Court.
Issues
- What is the precise territorial jurisdiction of criminal courts for trying offences under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
- Whether the five-jurisdiction formula in K. Bhaskaran was correctly decided in criminal law.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
The Drawee Bank as the Sole Venue of Offence
Vikramajit Sen, J. held that the commission of the offence under Section 138 is tied to the dishonour of the cheque. The dishonour occurs at the drawee bank where the account is maintained. The statutory notice under clause (b) of the proviso is merely a condition precedent for taking cognizance, not a part of the offence itself.
Rejection of Forum Shopping under K. Bhaskaran
The Court held that the five-place formula in K. Bhaskaran led to gross abuse where complainants deposited cheques in distant branches purely to harass drawers. Territorial jurisdiction lies strictly where the drawee bank is located.
Decision
Complaint returned for presentation before the court having territorial jurisdiction over the drawee bank at Nandurbar; K. Bhaskaran overruled.
Ratio decidendi
An offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act takes place at the drawee bank where the cheque is dishonoured; courts at that place alone possess territorial jurisdiction to try the complaint.
Exam points
- Overruled the five-jurisdiction rule of K. Bhaskaran (1999).
- Fixed jurisdiction solely at the drawee bank (where the drawer maintains the account).
- Prompted the Negotiable Instruments (Amendment) Act, 2015, which inserted Section 142(2) fixing jurisdiction at the payee’s collecting bank branch for account payee cheques.
- Classic illustration of legislative amendment overriding judicial precedent.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, NI Act, Section 138, Territorial Jurisdiction, Drawee Bank, Cheque Bounce