State of U.P. v. Deoman Upadhyaya (1960)

Supreme Court of India · AIR 1960 SC 1125 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

The 5-Judge Constitution Bench upheld the constitutional validity of Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (now Section 23 BSA) under Article 14 of the Constitution. The Court held that the classification between persons in police custody and persons not in police custody regarding information leading to discovery is reasonable and founded on an intelligible differentia aimed at preventing fabricated confessions.

Facts

  • Deoman Upadhyaya murdered his stepmother with a gandasa (chopper) following a dispute over property.
  • While in police custody, he made a statement: "I have buried the gandasa in the tank; I will dig it out and hand it over." He then led the police and panch witnesses to the tank and recovered the blood-stained weapon.
  • The Allahabad High Court held that Section 27 Evidence Act was discriminatory and void under Article 14 because it applied only to persons in police custody and not to accused persons at liberty.

Issues

  • Whether Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act violates the equal protection guarantee of Article 14 of the Constitution.
  • Whether the discovery of a weapon pursuant to information given in police custody is admissible in evidence.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Reasonable classification under Article 14

Shah, J. for the majority held that persons in police custody form a distinct, vulnerable class requiring protection against third-degree methods. While Section 25 and 26 broadly ban custodial confessions, Section 27 carves out a rational exception: where a distinct physical fact is discovered, the discovery guarantees truthfulness.

Doctrine of confirmation by subsequent facts

The rationale of Section 27 is the doctrine of confirmation by subsequent facts: if physical evidence (weapon, stolen property) is actually found where the accused stated it was hidden, that part of his statement is proved true and admissible.

Decision

High Court judgment reversed; Section 27 Evidence Act declared constitutionally valid under Article 14; conviction restored.

Ratio decidendi

The classification in Section 27 between accused persons in police custody and those not in custody is based on an intelligible differentia having a rational relation to the object of ensuring the truth of admissions.

Exam points

  • Upheld the constitutional validity of Section 27 Evidence Act (BSA Section 23) under Article 14.
  • Articulated the "doctrine of confirmation by subsequent facts".
  • Established that only the exact portion of information distinctly relating to the discovery is admissible.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, BSA, Evidence Act 27, BSA 23, Discovery, Article 14

All judgments