T. Devadasan v. Union of India (1964)
Supreme Court of India · AIR 1964 SC 179 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
The Constitution Bench by majority struck down the Union Government’s "carry-forward rule" which allowed unfilled reserved vacancies of SCs and STs to be accumulated for subsequent years, resulting in 64.4% of vacancies in the dispute year being reserved, holding that reservation in any single year cannot exceed 50%.
Facts
- The Central Government framed a "carry-forward rule" for recruitment to the Central Secretariat Service, providing that unfilled reserved vacancies would be carried over to the next year and then to the third year.
- In the 1960 examination, by operation of the carry-forward rule, 29 out of 45 appointments (64.4%) were reserved for SCs and STs.
- An unreserved candidate who scored higher than the qualified reserved candidates challenged the carry-forward rule under Article 16(1).
Issues
- Whether the carry-forward rule which resulted in reserving more than 50% vacancies in a recruitment year violates Article 16(1).
- Whether Article 16(4) can be applied in a manner that obliterates equality of opportunity under Article 16(1).
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Year as the unit of recruitment
The Court held that each year of recruitment must be considered independently; each year’s applicants form a distinct generation whose fundamental right to equal opportunity cannot be sacrificed to satisfy past unfilled quotas.
Application of the Balaji 50% limit to Article 16(4)
Applying the rule in Balaji, the Court held that reservation under Article 16(4) cannot exceed 50% of the vacancies available in any single year.
Decision
The carry-forward rule was struck down as unconstitutional.
Ratio decidendi
Reservation under Article 16(4) cannot exceed 50% of the vacancies filled in any single recruitment year, and the carry-forward mechanism cannot breach this ceiling.
Exam points
- Struck down carry-forward rule producing >50% reservation in a year.
- Later overruled in Indra Sawhney, which led to the 81st Constitutional Amendment inserting Art. 16(4B).
- Historic milestone in the evolution of Article 16 equality jurisprudence.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 16(4), Carry Forward Rule, Reservation