D.K. Yadav v. J.M.A. Industries Ltd. (1993)

Supreme Court of India · (1993) 3 SCC 259 · 3-Judge Bench

Summary

Landmark 3-judge bench decision holding that principles of natural justice (audi alteram partem) must be read into certified standing orders. Struck down the automatic termination/deemed abandonment of service of a workman for 8 days unauthorized absence without a prior fair hearing, holding that deprivation of livelihood violates Article 21 and Article 14.

Facts

  • D.K. Yadav was a permanent workman employed with J.M.A. Industries Ltd.
  • Clause 13(2)(iv) of the company Certified Standing Orders provided that if a workman remains absent without sanctioned leave for more than eight consecutive days, he shall be deemed to have abandoned his employment and lost his lien on appointment.
  • The workman remained absent from December 3, 1980 to December 12, 1980.
  • The management invoked Clause 13(2)(iv) and struck his name off the rolls without issuing a charge-sheet, notice, or departmental inquiry.
  • The Labour Court upheld the termination as contractual cessation under the standing orders.
  • The workman appealed to the Supreme Court.

Issues

  • Whether a clause in certified standing orders providing for automatic termination of employment on unauthorized absence can override principles of natural justice.
  • Whether the right to livelihood under Article 21 and protection against arbitrariness under Article 14 require an opportunity of hearing prior to termination of employment.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Natural justice read into statutory standing orders

K. Ramaswamy, J. held that certified standing orders must conform to the requirements of Articles 14 and 21. Natural justice is not an unruly horse; it permeates all statutory and administrative actions affecting civil rights. Even where a standing order provides for automatic cessation, the management must give the workman an opportunity to explain his absence.

Deprivation of livelihood requires just, fair, and reasonable procedure

Livelihood is an integral facet of the right to life under Article 21 (Olga Tellis). No person can be deprived of his livelihood except according to procedure established by law, which must be just, fair, and reasonable (Maneka Gandhi). Striking off a workman name without giving him an opportunity to demonstrate unavoidable causes violates Article 14 and 21.

Decision

Appeal allowed. Termination set aside and workman reinstated with 50% back wages. Certified standing orders cannot dispense with natural justice.

Ratio decidendi

Certified standing orders are subject to constitutional limitations under Articles 14 and 21. The right to life includes the right to livelihood. Depriving a person of employment without affording him an opportunity of showing cause or proving that absence was due to circumstances beyond his control is arbitrary, unjust, and void for violation of natural justice.

Exam points

  • Read natural justice (audi alteram partem) into certified standing orders.
  • Reaffirmed that the right to livelihood is protected under Article 21 in employment relationships.
  • Invalidated the doctrine of automatic abandonment of employment without inquiry.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Administrative Law, Labour, Natural Justice, Article 21, Standing Orders

All judgments