M/S Emaar MGF Land Limited v. Aftab Singh (2018)

Supreme Court of India · (2019) 12 SCC 751 · AIRONLINE 2018 SC 828 · Two-Judge Bench · 2018-12-10

Summary

The Supreme Court held that an arbitration agreement does not by itself oust consumer-forum jurisdiction. The consumer remedy is an additional statutory remedy, and a consumer forum is not required to refer the dispute to arbitration merely because an arbitration clause exists.

Facts

  • Homebuyers pursued consumer proceedings concerning disputes arising from their dealings with a real-estate developer.
  • The developer relied on an arbitration clause and sought reference under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
  • The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission treated the consumer remedy as available notwithstanding the arbitration agreement.
  • The Supreme Court considered whether the arbitration agreement compelled the consumer forum to refer the dispute to arbitration.

Issues

  • Whether an arbitration agreement bars a complaint before a consumer forum.
  • Whether Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act requires a consumer forum to refer the dispute to arbitration.
  • Whether the Consumer Protection Act remedy is additional to remedies under other laws.

Provisions involved

  • Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 — s. 8 — Reference to arbitration where there is an arbitration agreement
  • Consumer Protection Act, 1986 — s. 3 — Act not in derogation of other laws

Reasoning

Additional remedy

The consumer remedy operates in addition to remedies under other laws. An arbitration clause does not automatically extinguish the statutory consumer remedy.

Section 8

Section 8 does not require a consumer forum to surrender its statutory jurisdiction merely because the underlying contract contains an arbitration agreement.

Consumer protection

The consumer-protection framework provides a specialised statutory remedy, and an arbitral mechanism does not by itself displace that remedy.

Decision

The Supreme Court dismissed the review petitions and reaffirmed that consumer disputes could proceed before consumer fora notwithstanding an arbitration clause.

Ratio decidendi

The statutory consumer remedy is additional to remedies under other laws, and an arbitration clause does not, by itself, require a consumer forum to decline jurisdiction in favour of arbitration.

Exam points

  • An arbitration clause does not automatically oust consumer-forum jurisdiction.
  • Section 3 makes the consumer remedy additional to other legal remedies.
  • Distinguish contractual arbitration from a statutory consumer remedy.

Tags: consumer, arbitration, consumer-forum, section-8

All judgments