Energy Watchdog v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (2017)

Supreme Court of India · (2017) 14 SCC 80 · AIR 2017 SC 2131 · Two-Judge Bench · 2017-04-11

Summary

The Supreme Court considered force majeure, frustration and change in law in long-term power purchase agreements. It distinguished contractual force majeure governed by Section 32 of the Indian Contract Act from statutory frustration under Section 56. Mere commercial hardship, increased cost or an unforeseen rise in fuel prices does not by itself frustrate a contract. Where the contract allocates the relevant risk, the contractual allocation governs.

Facts

  • Power generating companies entered into long-term power purchase agreements for supply of electricity.
  • Changes affecting the availability and price of imported coal increased the cost of generation.
  • The generators sought relief on force majeure and change-in-law grounds, while regulatory authorities examined the contractual and statutory consequences.
  • The Supreme Court considered whether the changed economic circumstances frustrated the contracts or triggered contractual relief.

Issues

  • Whether the contractual force majeure provisions were attracted by the changed coal-price circumstances.
  • Whether Section 56 frustration applies where the contract itself provides for force majeure consequences.
  • Whether increased expense or commercial hardship is sufficient to discharge a contract.
  • How change-in-law provisions in power purchase agreements should be applied.

Provisions involved

  • Indian Contract Act, 1872 — s. 32 — Enforcement of contracts contingent on an event happening
  • Indian Contract Act, 1872 — s. 56 — Agreement to do impossible act

Reasoning

Contractual force majeure

Where parties have expressly provided for force majeure, the event and its consequences are principally governed by the contractual allocation under Section 32. The court must first examine the language of the bargain.

Frustration under Section 56

Section 56 operates where the supervening event falls outside the contractual allocation and makes performance impossible or radically different in the legal sense. It is not a general relief against a bad bargain.

Commercial hardship

A rise in price or increased financial burden does not ordinarily amount to frustration. A contract is not discharged merely because performance has become more expensive or less profitable.

Change in law

A contractual change-in-law clause must be applied according to its terms. Regulatory changes covered by the clause may have contractual consequences even though they do not independently frustrate the contract.

Decision

The Supreme Court rejected the contention that the relevant increase in coal cost, by itself, frustrated the power purchase agreements and applied the contractual framework governing force majeure and change in law.

Ratio decidendi

Where a contract contains a force majeure or change-in-law mechanism, the contractual allocation governs; Section 56 is not a doctrine for relieving parties from increased costs or commercial hardship alone.

Exam points

  • Distinguish Section 32 contractual force majeure from Section 56 frustration.
  • Commercial hardship and increased expense ordinarily do not constitute frustration.
  • Always read the contractual risk-allocation clause before invoking Section 56.

Tags: contract, force-majeure, frustration, section-32, section-56, electricity

All judgments