Fateh Chand v. Balkishan Dass (1963)

Supreme Court of India · AIR 1963 SC 1405 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

The 5-Judge Constitution Bench delivered the foundational ruling on Section 74 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. The Court held that Section 74 boldly cuts across the English common law distinction between "liquidated damages" and "penalty." In all cases where a sum is named or a penalty is stipulated, the aggrieved party is entitled only to "reasonable compensation" not exceeding the amount named, and must prove actual loss unless proof is impossible.

Facts

  • Balkishan Dass agreed to sell a piece of land and building in Delhi to Fateh Chand for Rs. 1,12,500.
  • Fateh Chand paid Rs. 1,000 as earnest money and Rs. 24,000 as part payment on taking possession, with the balance to be paid upon execution of the registered sale deed.
  • The agreement stipulated that if the buyer failed to pay the balance, the earnest money and the Rs. 24,000 part payment would stand forfeited.
  • The buyer defaulted; the seller rescinded the contract and forfeited the entire Rs. 25,000.

Issues

  • Whether a contractual covenant authorizing forfeiture of earnest money and advance part payment is governed by Section 74 of the Indian Contract Act.
  • Whether the seller can forfeit the entire stipulated sum without proving actual loss or damage suffered.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Section 74 abolishes English distinction between liquidated damages and penalty

Shah, J. held that Section 74 applies to all contracts stipulating an amount to be paid on breach. The aggrieved party receives reasonable compensation not exceeding the amount named, whether it is a penalty or liquidated damages.

Earnest money vs advance part payment

While a reasonable amount of earnest money paid as a guarantee of performance may be forfeited, substantial advance payments of price cannot be automatically forfeited without proving loss under Section 74. Since the seller proved no loss, he was allowed to forfeit only the earnest money of Rs. 1,000 plus reasonable compensation for use of the premises.

Decision

Forfeiture of Rs. 24,000 advance struck down; seller entitled only to Rs. 1,000 earnest money plus reasonable mesne profits.

Ratio decidendi

Under Section 74 of the Indian Contract Act, forfeiture of money paid under a contract upon breach must satisfy the test of reasonable compensation, and the distinction between liquidated damages and penalty does not apply in India.

Exam points

  • Constitution Bench benchmark on Section 74 Indian Contract Act.
  • Abolition of English common law dichotomy between liquidated damages and penalty in India.
  • Earnest money is forfeitable only if it is a reasonable guarantee of performance, not an oppressive penalty.
  • Party claiming damages must prove actual loss unless loss is incapable of assessment.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Contract, Section 74 ICA, Earnest Money, Liquidated Damages, Penalty

All judgments