Fortune Infrastructure (Now Known as Hicon Infrastructure) v. Trevor D’Lima (2018)

Supreme Court of India · (2018) 5 SCC 442 · 2018 INSC 233 · Two-Judge Bench · 2018-03-12

Summary

The Supreme Court held that a residential purchaser cannot be compelled to wait indefinitely for possession. Where the developer fails to deliver possession within the promised period and the circumstances justify termination, the consumer may seek refund with appropriate compensation.

Facts

  • Homebuyers had paid substantial amounts toward residential flats in a redevelopment project.
  • Possession was not delivered within the promised period, leading the purchasers to seek refund and compensation through consumer proceedings.

Issues

  • Whether a flat purchaser can be required to wait indefinitely for possession after substantial delay by the developer.
  • Whether the purchaser can terminate the transaction and seek refund with compensation.

Provisions involved

  • Consumer Protection Act, 1986 — s. 14 — Reliefs available to consumer
  • Indian Contract Act, 1872 — s. 73 — Compensation for loss or damage caused by breach of contract

Reasoning

Indefinite delay is not acceptable to a homebuyer

The Court recognised that a purchaser who has paid for a home cannot ordinarily be required to wait indefinitely for the developer to perform the promised obligation.

Refund as an appropriate consumer remedy

Where the delay and surrounding circumstances establish deficiency in service, refund of the amounts paid with appropriate compensation may be ordered rather than compelling the purchaser to accept delayed possession.

Decision

The appeals were allowed in part to the extent indicated by the Court, while the consumer purchasers were recognised as entitled to appropriate relief arising from the prolonged failure to provide possession.

Ratio decidendi

Where a developer fails to deliver possession within the promised period and the delay becomes inordinate, consumer law permits the purchaser to seek refund and appropriate compensation rather than being compelled to accept possession after an indefinite wait.

Exam points

  • Fortune Infrastructure is a leading delay-in-possession consumer case.
  • The principle was expressly relied on in Pioneer Urban Land & Infrastructure Ltd. v. Govindan Raghavan.
  • Distinguish refund for deficiency in service from damages governed solely by ordinary contract principles.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Consumer Protection, Real Estate, Housing

All judgments