Hindustan Construction Company Ltd. v. NHPC Ltd. & Anr. (2020)
Supreme Court of India · (2020) 4 SCC 310 · 2020 INSC 272 · Three-Judge Bench · 2020-03-04
Summary
The Supreme Court held that where the parties have designated the seat of arbitration, the courts at that seat exercise exclusive supervisory jurisdiction over the arbitral proceedings and applications for setting aside the award. A court at another place cannot retain jurisdiction merely because part of the cause of action arose there.
Facts
- The parties entered into a contract containing an arbitration agreement and disputes were referred to arbitration.
- The lower court found New Delhi to be the chosen seat of arbitration but nevertheless treated Faridabad as having jurisdiction because part of the cause of action arose there.
- A Section 34 challenge to the arbitral award had been filed before the court at Faridabad.
- The Supreme Court considered the effect of the designated seat and the interaction of Sections 20 and 42 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
Issues
- Whether designation of New Delhi as the seat of arbitration conferred exclusive jurisdiction on courts at New Delhi.
- Whether a court where part of the cause of action arose could exercise concurrent jurisdiction over the Section 34 challenge.
- How Section 42 operates when an application is made to a court that is not the competent court at the arbitral seat.
Reasoning
Designated seat as jurisdictional anchor
The Court applied the seat theory: once the parties choose a juridical seat, the courts exercising supervisory jurisdiction over that seat have exclusive jurisdiction over the arbitration.
Section 42
Section 42 operates among competent courts exercising jurisdiction under Part I. It does not transform an application filed in a court lacking territorial jurisdiction into a basis for exclusive jurisdiction.
Section 34 challenge
A challenge to an arbitral award under Section 34 must be presented before the court having supervisory jurisdiction at the designated seat.
Decision
The Supreme Court set aside the impugned order and directed that the Section 34 proceedings be transferred to the Delhi High Court at New Delhi. The connected transfer petitions were allowed.
Ratio decidendi
The juridical seat of arbitration determines the court exercising supervisory jurisdiction. Section 42 does not confer exclusive jurisdiction on a court that was approached first but lacks jurisdiction over the arbitration; a designated seat operates as an exclusive jurisdictional anchor.
Exam points
- Seat of arbitration is distinct from a mere venue.
- The designated seat ordinarily identifies the court with exclusive supervisory jurisdiction.
- Section 42 cannot create jurisdiction in a court that otherwise lacks it.
Tags: arbitration, seat, jurisdiction, section-34, section-42