M/s. Imperia Structures Ltd. v. Anil Patni (2020)
Supreme Court of India · (2020) 10 SCC 783 · 2020 INSC 625 · Two-Judge Bench · 2020-11-02
Summary
The Supreme Court held that the remedies under the Consumer Protection Act are additional remedies and that the RERA Act does not bar a consumer who falls within the statutory definition from approaching consumer fora. The decision addressed the coexistence of consumer remedies with the real-estate regulatory framework.
Facts
- Homebuyers approached consumer fora seeking relief concerning delay and other deficiencies in real-estate projects.
- The developer argued that the enactment of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 displaced or barred the consumer remedy.
Issues
- Whether the RERA Act bars a homebuyer who qualifies as a consumer from invoking the Consumer Protection Act.
- Whether the remedies under the two enactments can operate concurrently.
Provisions involved
- Consumer Protection Act, 1986 — s. 2(1)(d) — Consumer
- Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 — s. 18 — Return of amount and compensation
Reasoning
Consumer remedy as an additional remedy
The Court reaffirmed the established principle that consumer remedies can operate in addition to remedies under other statutes unless the later legislation clearly excludes the consumer jurisdiction.
RERA does not create an exclusive consumer-remedy bar
The Court compared the statutory schemes and concluded that RERA did not contain a provision making the remedies under the Consumer Protection Act unavailable to a qualifying consumer.
Decision
The appeals were dismissed and the Court upheld the maintainability of consumer proceedings in the circumstances considered.
Ratio decidendi
The RERA Act does not impliedly bar the consumer jurisdiction where the complainant satisfies the Consumer Protection Act requirements. Consumer remedies are additional unless the governing statute clearly excludes them.
Exam points
- Imperia Structures is a leading authority on the interaction between RERA and consumer jurisdiction.
- Distinguish statutory remedies from a rule of exclusive jurisdiction.
- Section 18 RERA expressly contemplates relief without prejudice to other remedies.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Consumer Protection, RERA, Real Estate