Indra Sawhney v. Union of India (1992)

Supreme Court of India · (1992) Supp (3) SCC 217 · 9-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

A 9-Judge Bench upheld reservations for Other Backward Classes under Article 16(4), subject to the exclusion of the creamy layer, and held that total reservations should ordinarily not exceed 50%. It also held that reservations in promotions were not contemplated by Article 16(4) as then interpreted (later addressed by constitutional amendments and M. Nagaraj).

Facts

  • The Mandal Commission recommended reservations for socially and educationally backward classes in central services.
  • Office Memoranda implementing OBC reservations were challenged as violative of equality under Articles 14 and 16.

Issues

  • Whether reservations for OBCs under Article 16(4) are constitutionally valid and on what conditions.
  • Whether a 50% ceiling applies and whether the creamy layer must be excluded.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Article 16(4) and backward classes

The Court upheld the power to reserve posts for backward classes of citizens not adequately represented in services, and accepted that caste can be a relevant starting point for identifying social backwardness in India, subject to exclusion of the advanced creamy layer.

50% ceiling and promotions

Reservations should ordinarily not exceed 50%. The Court also held that Article 16(4) did not permit reservations in promotions — a holding later modified by constitutional amendment and examined in M. Nagaraj.

Decision

OBC reservations upheld with creamy-layer exclusion and the 50% rule as the ordinary ceiling. The judgment remains the foundational authority on Article 16(4) and reservation doctrine.

Ratio decidendi

Article 16(4) enables reservations for backward classes not adequately represented in services, but equality requires exclusion of the creamy layer and, ordinarily, adherence to a 50% ceiling on total reservations.

Exam points

  • Creamy layer exclusion mandatory for OBCs.
  • 50% ceiling as ordinary rule.
  • Mandal / OBC reservations upheld under Article 16(4).
  • Promotions: original holding later altered by amendment + Nagaraj line.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Reservation, Article 16, Mandal, Equality

All judgments