Innoventive Industries Ltd. v. ICICI Bank (2018)
Supreme Court of India · (2018) 1 SCC 407 · 2-Judge Bench
Summary
The foundational Magna Carta of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. Settled the scheme of corporate insolvency resolution under Section 7 and 9 IBC, held that Section 238 IBC overrides state relief acts (Maharashtra Relief Undertaking Act), and ruled that once default is established, the NCLT has no discretion but to admit the insolvency application.
Facts
- Innoventive Industries defaulted on bank credit facilities extended by ICICI Bank.
- ICICI Bank filed an insolvency application under Section 7 IBC before the NCLT, Mumbai.
- The corporate debtor opposed admission relying on notifications issued by the Government of Maharashtra under the Maharashtra Relief Undertaking (Special Provisions) Act, 1958, which suspended all remedies against the debtor for two years.
- The NCLT and NCLAT held that the IBC overrides state relief legislations. The company appealed to the Supreme Court.
Issues
- Whether the non-obstante clause in Section 238 IBC overrides state enactments like the Maharashtra Relief Undertaking Act under Article 254.
- What is the threshold test for admitting a financial creditor petition under Section 7 IBC.
Provisions involved
- Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 — s. Section 7 & Section 238 — Initiation of CIRP by financial creditor and overriding effect of the Code
Reasoning
Section 238 IBC prevails over conflicting laws
Nariman, J. held that under Article 254 of the Constitution read with Section 238 IBC, the provisions of the IBC prevail over any contrary or inconsistent provisions contained in any other state or central law.
The simple test of default under Section 7
For a financial creditor under Section 7, the adjudicating authority (NCLT) must merely ascertain whether a "default" has occurred. If the financial debt is owed and default has occurred and the application is complete, the NCLT must admit the petition. The debtor cannot set up disputed claims or set-offs against a financial creditor.
Decision
Appeal dismissed. NCLAT order admitting ICICI Bank Section 7 application upheld. Corporate debtor moratorium plea rejected.
Ratio decidendi
Under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, once a financial creditor establishes that a debt is due and default has occurred, the NCLT has no jurisdiction to look into extraneous disputes or state moratoriums. By virtue of Section 238 IBC, the Code overrides any inconsistent state or central enactments.
Exam points
- The first major Supreme Court ruling expounding the IBC framework.
- Section 238 non-obstante clause overrides state relief undertaking laws.
- Under Section 7 IBC, only the existence of debt and default matters.
Tags: AIBE, Commercial Law, IBC, Section 7, Section 238, NCLT, Insolvency Resolution