I.R. Coelho v. State of Tamil Nadu (2007)
Supreme Court of India · (2007) 2 SCC 1 · 9-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
A 9-Judge Bench held that laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973 (the date of Kesavananda) are open to judicial review on the touchstone of the basic structure. Article 31B does not confer a blanket immunity from basic-structure scrutiny.
Facts
- Successive amendments had inserted numerous laws into the Ninth Schedule under Article 31B to protect them from fundamental-rights challenges.
- The question referred was whether such insertion confers absolute immunity even when the law damages the basic structure.
Issues
- Whether laws inserted into the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973 are immune from basic-structure review.
- What is the standard of judicial review applicable to Ninth Schedule laws?
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Kesavananda as the cut-off
The Court treated 24 April 1973 as the watershed: laws inserted into the Ninth Schedule after that date must face basic-structure review.
No absolute immunity
Article 31B does not authorise Parliament to destroy or damage the basic structure by the device of Ninth Schedule insertion; judicial review on that ground remains available.
Decision
Post-Kesavananda Ninth Schedule insertions are open to basic-structure challenge. The judgment is the leading modern authority on the limits of Article 31B.
Ratio decidendi
Article 31B cannot confer absolute immunity from basic-structure review; any post-24 April 1973 Ninth Schedule law that damages basic features is liable to be struck down.
Exam points
- Ninth Schedule post-24 April 1973 = open to basic-structure review.
- Article 31B is not a blank cheque against basic features.
- 9-Judge Bench; high-yield with Kesavananda and Minerva Mills.
- Distinguish pre- and post-Kesavananda insertions.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Ninth Schedule, Basic Structure, Article 31B