Janhit Abhiyan v. Union of India (2022)

Supreme Court of India · (2023) 5 SCC 1 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

By a 3:2 majority, the Court upheld the Constitution (One Hundred and Third Amendment) Act, 2019 enabling up to 10% reservation for Economically Weaker Sections (EWS) among the non-SC/ST/OBC population under Articles 15(6) and 16(6), holding that economic criteria and the breach of the ordinary 50% ceiling for this segment do not destroy the basic structure.

Facts

  • The 103rd Amendment inserted Articles 15(6) and 16(6) to permit special provisions including reservation for EWS other than the classes covered by existing SC/ST/OBC reservations.
  • Petitions challenged the amendment as violative of the equality code and the 50% ceiling associated with Indra Sawhney.

Issues

  • Whether reservation based solely on economic criteria violates the basic structure.
  • Whether EWS reservation for non-SC/ST/OBC classes, including beyond the ordinary 50% ceiling, is constitutionally valid.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Economic criteria permissible

The majority held that economic disadvantage can be a legitimate basis for affirmative action and that the 103rd Amendment does not destroy the basic structure of equality.

50% ceiling and exclusion of SC/ST/OBC

The majority treated the 50% ceiling as a rule applicable to the earlier reservation framework and held that a separate EWS segment with its own ceiling did not per se violate the basic structure; the exclusion of SC/ST/OBC from EWS was sustained as those classes already have reservation benefits.

Decision

103rd Amendment upheld by 3:2. Dissenting opinions raised concerns about equality and the exclusion of the poorest among SC/ST/OBC from EWS. The case is the leading authority on EWS reservation.

Ratio decidendi

Parliament may provide reservation for economically weaker sections among classes not covered by SC/ST/OBC reservations; such a measure does not, by itself, violate the basic structure of equality.

Exam points

  • 103rd Amendment / EWS upheld 3:2.
  • Economic criteria can support reservation.
  • Debate on 50% ceiling and exclusion of SC/ST/OBC — majority vs dissent.
  • Pair with Indra Sawhney in answers.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Reservation, EWS, Equality, Basic Structure

All judgments