Jarnail Singh v. Lachhmi Narain Gupta (2018)

Supreme Court of India · (2018) 10 SCC 396 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

A Constitution Bench partially modified M. Nagaraj: States need not collect quantifiable data on the backwardness of SCs/STs as a precondition for reservation in promotion, but the creamy layer principle applies to SCs/STs in promotion, and the requirements of inadequate representation and administrative efficiency remain.

Facts

  • After M. Nagaraj upheld Articles 16(4A)/(4B) subject to quantifiable data tests, multiple challenges and references arose on whether SC/ST backwardness data and creamy layer applied to promotion reservations.
  • The matter was placed before a Constitution Bench to clarify Nagaraj.

Issues

  • Whether quantifiable data on backwardness of SCs/STs is required for reservation in promotion after Nagaraj.
  • Whether the creamy layer principle applies to SCs/STs in the context of promotion reservations.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

No quantifiable data on SC/ST backwardness

The Court held that Nagaraj was incorrect to the extent it required the State to show quantifiable data on the backwardness of SCs/STs — these classes are already identified in the Constitution as backward for the purposes of reservation.

Creamy layer applies

The creamy layer principle was held applicable to SCs/STs in promotion reservations so that the benefit reaches the weaker sections within the class, while tests of inadequate representation and efficiency under Article 335 continue.

Decision

Nagaraj was modified: no quantifiable backwardness data for SCs/STs; creamy layer applies; inadequate representation and efficiency tests remain. The judgment is essential reading with Indra Sawhney and Nagaraj.

Ratio decidendi

Constitutional identification of SCs/STs dispenses with a further quantifiable-data test of backwardness for promotion reservation, but equality within the class requires creamy-layer exclusion, subject to representation and efficiency constraints.

Exam points

  • Modifies Nagaraj: no quantifiable backwardness data for SC/ST promotions.
  • Creamy layer applies to SCs/STs in promotion.
  • Inadequate representation + Art. 335 efficiency still required.
  • Read with Indra Sawhney and Nagaraj as a trilogy.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Reservation, Promotion, Creamy Layer, SC/ST

All judgments