Joseph Shine v. Union of India (2018)
Supreme Court of India · (2019) 3 SCC 39 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
A Constitution Bench struck down Section 497 IPC (adultery) and the related procedural provision in Section 198(2) CrPC as unconstitutional, holding that the colonial offence treated women as property of husbands and violated Articles 14, 15 and 21.
Facts
- A writ petition under Article 32 challenged the constitutional validity of Section 497 IPC, which criminalised adultery in a manner that only the man could be an offender and only the husband was an aggrieved person.
- The petition argued that the provision was archaic, gendered, and inconsistent with equality and dignity.
Issues
- Whether Section 497 IPC violates Articles 14, 15 and 21.
- Whether criminalisation of adultery as framed under Section 497 is a valid restriction on personal liberty and equality.
Provisions involved
- Indian Penal Code, 1860 — s. Section 497 IPC — Adultery
- Constitution of India — Art. Article 14 — Equality before law
Reasoning
Gendered subordination
The Court held that Section 497 was based on a paternalistic notion that women are chattel of their husbands and lacked agency; such a classification violates equality and non-discrimination.
Privacy, dignity and the criminal law
Building on privacy and dignity jurisprudence, the Court held that the criminal law cannot enforce a patriarchal conception of marriage by selectively punishing one party to a consensual relationship.
Decision
Section 497 IPC and Section 198(2) CrPC to the extent of the adultery framework were struck down. Adultery remains relevant as a civil ground in matrimonial law but is not a criminal offence under the struck provision.
Ratio decidendi
A penal provision that institutionalises gender stereotypes and denies women equal agency in intimate relations violates equality, non-discrimination, and the right to live with dignity.
Exam points
- Section 497 IPC struck down as unconstitutional.
- Adultery not a crime under the invalidated provision; may remain a civil matrimonial ground.
- Equality, dignity, and rejection of patriarchal stereotypes central to the holding.
- Decided by a 5-Judge Constitution Bench (2018).
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Gender, Equality, IPC, Privacy