K.M. Nanavati v. State of Maharashtra (1962)

Supreme Court of India · AIR 1962 SC 605 · 3-Judge Bench

Summary

The Court examined the defence of grave and sudden provocation in a high-profile homicide, clarifying that provocation must be such as would deprive a reasonable person of self-control and that the response must be traced to the provocation without cooling time.

Facts

  • Naval officer K.M. Nanavati shot Prem Ahuja after learning of an affair involving his wife.
  • Issues of jury trial, gubernatorial suspension of sentence, and the provocation exception arose in the appellate history.

Issues

  • Whether the killing fell within Exception 1 to Section 300 IPC (grave and sudden provocation).

Provisions involved

  • BNS / IPC (historical) — s. Exception 1 to Section 300 IPC (provocation) — Grave and sudden provocation

Reasoning

Reasonable person test

Provocation is judged by whether a reasonable person in the accused’s situation would lose self-control; mere anger after an interval is insufficient.

Decision

The conviction trajectory and the doctrinal discussion of provocation make Nanavati a standard citation on Exception 1 to Section 300 IPC (and corresponding BNS homicide exceptions).

Ratio decidendi

Exception 1 to Section 300 applies only when provocation is grave and sudden and the act is committed while deprived of self-control, not after time for passion to cool.

Exam points

  • Grave and sudden provocation elements.
  • Cooling time defeats the exception.
  • Classic criminal law exam case.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Murder, Provocation, IPC/BNS

All judgments