Kasturi Lal Ralia Ram Jain v. State of U.P. (1965)

Supreme Court of India · AIR 1965 SC 1039 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

The 5-Judge Constitution Bench held that the State is not vicariously liable for tortious acts committed by its public servants in the exercise of delegated sovereign powers. The Court denied compensation to a bullion merchant whose gold was seized by police on suspicion and subsequently stolen by a head constable who absconded to Pakistan. Although followed on Article 300, the harshness of this ruling led the Supreme Court to develop the doctrine of constitutional tort under Article 32.

Facts

  • Kasturi Lal, a partner in a bullion firm, arrived in Meerut to sell gold and silver. Three police constables seized the gold (over 100 tolas) on suspicion of being stolen property.
  • The gold was kept in the police malkhana under the custody of Head Constable Mohammad Amir, who misappropriated the gold and fled to Pakistan.
  • Kasturi Lal sued the State of U.P. for the return of the gold or its value (Rs. 11,075), contending that the State was vicariously liable for the negligence and theft of its police officers.

Issues

  • Whether the State of U.P. was vicariously liable under Article 300 for the tortious misappropriation of seized property by its police servants.
  • What constitutes the exercise of a "sovereign function" shielding the State from civil liability in tort.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Distinction between sovereign and non-sovereign functions

Gajendragadkar, C.J. traced the historical liability of the East India Company from the P&O Steam Navigation Co. case (1861). The Court held that if a tortious act is committed by a public servant in the discharge of statutory duties which are referable to the exercise of sovereign power (such as maintaining law and order or seizing property), the State is immune from liability.

Sovereign nature of arrest and seizure

The power to arrest, search, and seize property under the CrPC can only be exercised by police officers acting as sovereign agents. Since the seizure was in exercise of sovereign power, the State cannot be held vicariously liable for the head constable’s crime.

Decision

Suit against the State dismissed on the ground of sovereign immunity; Court urged Parliament to enact legislation defining State liability.

Ratio decidendi

Under Article 300 of the Constitution, the State is not vicariously liable in tort for the negligence or criminal acts of its public servants if the act was committed in the discharge of sovereign functions.

Exam points

  • Benchmark decision on Sovereign Immunity under Article 300.
  • Held police power of arrest and seizure is a sovereign function shielding the State from civil tort liability.
  • Led to subsequent bypass through public law constitutional tort under Article 32/226 (Rudul Sah, Nilabati Behera).

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Tort, Article 300, Sovereign Immunity, Vicarious Liability, Kasturi Lal

All judgments