Kaushal Kishor v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2023)
Supreme Court of India · (2023) 4 SCC 1 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
Constitution Bench precedent holding that the fundamental rights under Articles 19 and 21 are enforceable horizontally against non-State actors and private individuals, not merely vertically against the State. Held that no additional restrictions can be imposed on the free speech of Ministers and public functionaries beyond the exhaustive grounds in Article 19(2), and statements made by Ministers cannot be vicariously attributed to the State.
Facts
- In a sensational gang-rape case on the National Highway near Bulandshahr, Uttar Pradesh, a senior State Cabinet Minister made public statements to the press terming the incident a "political conspiracy" to malign the state government.
- The victims and their families approached the Supreme Court under Article 32, aggrieved that public statements by ministers undermined a fair investigation and violated their dignity under Article 21.
- Questions arose regarding whether restrictions beyond Article 19(2) can be placed on speech by persons holding high public office, and whether Articles 19 and 21 can be enforced horizontally against private persons.
Issues
- Whether the grounds of reasonable restriction on free speech in Article 19(2) are exhaustive, or can be supplemented by other fundamental rights like Article 21 dignity.
- Whether fundamental rights under Articles 19 and 21 can be enforced against persons other than the State (horizontal application).
- Whether a statement made by a Minister can be vicariously attributed to the Government under the principle of collective responsibility.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Horizontal application of Articles 19 and 21
Ramasubramanian, J. for the majority held that a fundamental right under Article 19 or 21 can be enforced even against persons other than the State or its instrumentalities. Following global constitutional trends, where private power causes a grave violation of bodily autonomy or liberty, constitutional courts can grant relief under Article 32 and 226.
Exhaustive nature of Article 19(2) and Minister statements
The eight grounds of restriction in Article 19(2) are exhaustive; no additional restrictions can be judicially grafted on the speech of public functionaries. Furthermore, a statement made by a Minister cannot be vicariously attributed to the Government unless it represents official government policy approved by the Cabinet.
Decision
Reference answered. Held that Articles 19 and 21 have horizontal application, restrictions under Article 19(2) are exhaustive, and minister statements are individual and not vicariously governmental.
Ratio decidendi
A fundamental right under Article 19 or Article 21 can be enforced against persons other than the State or its instrumentalities. The grounds specified in Article 19(2) are exhaustive, and no additional restrictions can be imported on the free speech of Ministers. A statement made by a Minister, even if touching upon state affairs, cannot be vicariously attributed to the Government under collective responsibility unless endorsed by the Council of Ministers.
Exam points
- Affirmed the horizontal applicability of Articles 19 and 21 against private non-state actors.
- Settled that the grounds of reasonable restriction in Article 19(2) are completely exhaustive.
- Clarified that individual utterances of Ministers cannot be attributed to the State Government.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 19, Article 21, Horizontal Application, Fundamental Rights