Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. M/s Girdharilal Parshottamdas & Co. (1966)
Supreme Court of India · AIR 1966 SC 543 · 3-Judge Bench
Summary
The 3-Judge Bench settled the place of formation of contracts concluded via instantaneous modes of communication (telephone, telex) in Indian law. Following the English rule in Entores Ltd v. Miles Far East Corp, the majority held that Section 4 of the Indian Contract Act does not apply to instantaneous telephone conversations; the contract is completed only when the acceptance is received and heard by the offeror, and the cause of action arises at the place where the acceptance is heard.
Facts
- The plaintiff firm, based in Ahmedabad, made an oral offer over long-distance telephone to the defendant firm in Khamgaon (Maharashtra) for the purchase of cotton seed cake.
- The defendant at Khamgaon accepted the offer over the telephone, which was heard and received by the plaintiff at Ahmedabad.
- When the defendant failed to deliver the goods, the plaintiff instituted a suit for breach of contract in the City Civil Court at Ahmedabad.
- The defendant filed an objection under Section 20 CPC, contending that the contract was made at Khamgaon where the acceptance was spoken, and hence Ahmedabad courts had no territorial jurisdiction.
Issues
- Where is a contract concluded when the offer and acceptance are exchanged over telephone (instantaneous communication).
- Whether Section 4 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 applies to instantaneous telephone communications as it does to postal contracts.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Instantaneous communication versus postal rule
Shah, J. for the majority held that Section 4 of the Contract Act was drafted to deal with communication through non-instantaneous post and messengers where an unavoidable time-gap exists. When parties negotiate by telephone, they are in instantaneous contact, and the postal rule does not apply.
Adoption of the Entores doctrine
The majority approved the English Court of Appeal decision in Entores: an oral acceptance spoken into a telephone does not make a binding contract until it is heard and understood by the offeror. Since the acceptance was heard at Ahmedabad, the contract was made at Ahmedabad, and the City Civil Court had territorial jurisdiction.
Decision
Objection dismissed; held that Ahmedabad City Civil Court had jurisdiction to try the suit.
Ratio decidendi
In contracts concluded by telephone or instantaneous communication, the contract is complete only when acceptance is received and heard by the proposer, and the cause of action arises at the place where acceptance is heard.
Exam points
- Locus classicus on contracts concluded by telephone in Indian law.
- Distinction between postal rule (Adams v. Lindsell) and instantaneous communication rule (Entores).
- Contract is complete at the place where the offeror hears the acceptance.
- Territorial jurisdiction under Section 20 CPC lies at the offeror’s location.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Contract, Section 4 ICA, Telephone Contract, Jurisdiction, Entores