Khoday Distilleries Ltd. v. State of Karnataka (1995)
Supreme Court of India · (1995) 1 SCC 574 · Constitution Bench (5 Judges)
Summary
Landmark 5-Judge Constitution Bench summarizing the constitutional principles governing trade in potable liquor. Held that citizens have no fundamental right under Article 19(1)(g) to trade or do business in potable liquor, as it is a noxious and dangerous substance falling under res extra commercium. The State has the exclusive right and privilege to manufacture, distribute, and sell liquor.
Facts
- The State of Karnataka and other State Governments amended their respective excise rules establishing a state monopoly over the wholesale and retail distribution of potable liquor.
- Private distillers, brewers, and wholesale distributors were prohibited from selling potable liquor directly to retailers or consumers, mandating routing solely through state beverage corporations.
- Manufacturers and distributors challenged the constitutional validity of these regulations, claiming violation of their fundamental right to trade and business under Article 19(1)(g).
- The High Court dismissed the petitions, and the matter was referred to a 5-Judge Constitution Bench to reconcile prior divergent rulings.
Issues
- Whether a citizen has a fundamental right under Article 19(1)(g) to carry on trade or business in potable liquor.
- Whether the State has the exclusive privilege and power to monopolize or prohibit the manufacture and sale of potable liquor under Entry 8 of List II and Article 47 of the Constitution.
Provisions involved
- Constitution of India — Art. Article 19(1)(g) & 19(6) — Freedom of trade, business, and reasonable restrictions
- Constitution of India — Art. Article 47 — Duty of the State to raise the level of nutrition and to improve public health
Reasoning
Potable liquor is res extra commercium
Sawant, J. laid down comprehensive propositions: Potable liquor, being injurious to health, is res extra commercium. A citizen has no fundamental right to trade or do business in activities which are inherently vicious and pernicious to societal health and peace.
Exclusive privilege and monopoly of the State
Because there is no fundamental right to trade in liquor, the State has the exclusive right and privilege to manufacture, distribute, and sell it. The State may part with this privilege for a fee or retain an absolute monopoly over its wholesale distribution. Article 19(1)(g) cannot be invoked against state regulation or takeover of liquor distribution.
Distinction between industrial alcohol and potable liquor
The Court clarified that while potable alcohol falls outside Article 19(1)(g), industrial alcohol and medicinal preparations containing alcohol are ordinary commercial goods entitled to constitutional protection under Article 19(1)(g), subject to reasonable regulatory restrictions under Article 19(6).
Decision
Appeals dismissed. Held that state excise regulations monopolizing the wholesale distribution of potable liquor are constitutionally valid.
Ratio decidendi
Trade in potable liquor is res extra commercium. Citizens do not possess a fundamental right under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India to carry on trade or commerce in potable liquor. The State has the exclusive right, privilege, and authority under Entry 8 of List II read with Article 47 to monopolize, control, or prohibit its production, possession, and commercial distribution.
Exam points
- Doctrine of Res Extra Commercium applied to potable liquor under Article 19(1)(g).
- Summary of 16 constitutional propositions regarding liquor trade laid down by Sawant, J.
- Distinction between potable alcohol and industrial alcohol in constitutional law.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 19(1)(g), Article 47, Liquor Monopoly