Kihoto Hollohan v. Zachillhu (1992)

Supreme Court of India · (1992) Supp (2) SCC 651 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

The Court upheld the Tenth Schedule (anti-defection law) in substance, but struck down Paragraph 7 to the extent it barred judicial review of the Speaker’s orders. The Speaker’s decision under the Tenth Schedule remains subject to judicial review on limited grounds such as mala fides, perversity, and violation of natural justice.

Facts

  • The Constitution (Fifty-second Amendment) Act, 1985 inserted the Tenth Schedule to curb political defections.
  • Challenges were raised to the Speaker’s adjudicatory role and to Paragraph 7, which sought to exclude the jurisdiction of courts in respect of disqualification matters.

Issues

  • Whether the Tenth Schedule is constitutionally valid.
  • Whether Paragraph 7 validly ousts judicial review of the Speaker’s disqualification decisions.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Tenth Schedule largely upheld

The Court sustained the anti-defection scheme as a legitimate constitutional experiment to curb unprincipled defections and protect the stability of governments.

Paragraph 7 and judicial review

Paragraph 7, insofar as it totally excluded judicial review, was held unconstitutional. The Speaker’s order is subject to judicial review on grounds such as mala fides, perversity, and breach of constitutional mandates including natural justice.

Decision

Tenth Schedule upheld; Paragraph 7 struck down to the extent of ouster of judicial review. The judgment is the locus classicus on anti-defection and Speaker’s jurisdiction.

Ratio decidendi

Anti-defection disqualification may be entrusted to the Speaker, but judicial review cannot be wholly excluded; finality clauses that destroy judicial review of constitutional disqualifications violate the basic structure.

Exam points

  • Tenth Schedule upheld; Paragraph 7 (ouster) struck down.
  • Speaker’s order reviewable on limited grounds (mala fides, perversity, natural justice).
  • Anti-defection vs legislative freedom balance.
  • High-yield for both constitutional law and polity-style questions.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Anti-Defection, Tenth Schedule, Speaker

All judgments