L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India (1997)
Supreme Court of India · (1997) 3 SCC 261 · 7-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
The 7-Judge Constitution Bench unanimously held that the power of judicial review vested in the High Courts under Articles 226/227 and in the Supreme Court under Article 32 is an integral and untruncatable part of the basic structure of the Constitution. The Court struck down provisions of Articles 323A and 323B and Section 28 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 that excluded the jurisdiction of High Courts, ruling that all decisions of tribunals are subject to scrutiny by a Division Bench of the High Court.
Facts
- Articles 323A and 323B (inserted by the 42nd Amendment) empowered Parliament and State Legislatures to establish tribunals for service and other disputes and exclude the jurisdiction of all courts except the Supreme Court under Article 136.
- Section 28 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 (the "exclusion of jurisdiction" clause) ousted High Court jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227.
- Litigants challenged the validity of these exclusion clauses, contending that judicial review by High Courts is part of the basic structure.
Issues
- Whether the exclusion of the jurisdiction of High Courts under Articles 226 and 227 by Articles 323A/323B and Section 28 of the Administrative Tribunals Act violates the basic structure.
- Whether administrative tribunals can act as supplemental or substitute forums for High Courts.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Judicial review under Articles 226/227 and 32 is Basic Structure
Ahmadi, C.J. held that the power of judicial review over legislative action and administrative action vested in High Courts under Article 226/227 and the Supreme Court under Article 32 is an inviolable basic feature of the Constitution that cannot be ousted by constitutional amendment or statute.
Tribunals as supplemental courts of first instance
Tribunals can perform a supplemental role as courts of first instance, but they can never substitute the High Courts. All decisions of tribunals are appealable before a Division Bench of the respective High Court before approaching the Supreme Court.
Decision
Exclusion clauses in Articles 323A(2)(d), 323B(3)(d), and Section 28 Administrative Tribunals Act struck down; tribunal orders made appealable to High Court Division Benches.
Ratio decidendi
Judicial review under Articles 226, 227, and 32 is part of the basic structure of the Constitution; statutory exclusion of High Court jurisdiction is ultra vires.
Exam points
- Held judicial review under Arts. 226, 227, and 32 is basic structure.
- Struck down Section 28 Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985.
- Established that all tribunal decisions must be challenged before a High Court Division Bench first.
- Tribunals cannot test the constitutional validity of their own parent statutes.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Basic Structure, Tribunals, Judicial Review, Article 226