Laxmi v. Union of India (2014)
Supreme Court of India · (2014) 4 SCC 427 · 2-Judge Bench
Summary
Historic public interest litigation judgment revolutionizing legal protections for acid attack survivors. Formulated nationwide binding directions restricting over-the-counter sales of corrosive acid, mandated photo ID and logbooks for buyers, and ordered minimum victim compensation of Rs. 3 Lakh and 100% free medical treatment in all public and private hospitals under Section 357C CrPC (now Section 397 BNSS).
Facts
- Laxmi, an acid attack survivor who suffered horrific facial disfigurement at age 15 for rejecting a marriage proposal, filed a PIL under Article 32.
- She highlighted the unrestricted over-the-counter sale of hazardous acids (hydrochloric, sulfuric) for nominal sums of Rs. 20–30, and the total lack of medical rehabilitation for survivors.
- During proceedings, Parliament enacted the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013, inserting Sections 326A and 326B IPC and Sections 357B and 357C CrPC.
- The Supreme Court issued nationwide operational guidelines to implement these provisions effectively.
Issues
- How to regulate the retail sale of acid to prevent hazardous misuse.
- What minimum statutory compensation and medical treatment must be guaranteed to acid attack survivors under Article 21.
Provisions involved
- Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 / IPC — s. Sections 326A & 326B IPC / Sections 124(1) & 124(2) BNS — Voluntarily causing grievous hurt by use of acid
- Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 / CrPC — s. Sections 357B & 357C CrPC / Sections 396 & 397 BNSS — Compensation to acid attack victims and mandatory free treatment by all hospitals
Reasoning
Strict regulation on retail sale of acid
Lodha, C.J. framed binding rules: (1) Over-the-counter sale of acid prohibited unless seller maintains a register of buyers; (2) Buyer must produce photo ID showing address and specify the purpose of purchase; (3) Ban on sale of acid to any person below 18 years; (4) Unaccounted acid to be confiscated with heavy fines.
Mandatory victim compensation and free medical treatment
All State Governments directed to pay minimum compensation of Rs. 3 Lakh per acid attack victim (Rs. 1 Lakh within 15 days for emergency care). All hospitals (public and private) mandated under Section 357C CrPC to provide immediate, complete, and free medical treatment including reconstructive surgeries.
Decision
Binding directions issued nationwide regulating acid sales, mandating minimum compensation of Rs. 3 Lakh, and imposing penal liability on hospitals denying free treatment.
Ratio decidendi
Under Article 21 of the Constitution read with Sections 357B and 357C CrPC, the State is under a constitutional obligation to provide minimum compensation of Rs. 3 Lakh to acid attack survivors. All hospitals, whether public or private, are bound to provide immediate, 100% free medical treatment and reconstructive surgery without delay.
Exam points
- Mandated minimum Rs. 3 Lakh victim compensation for acid attack survivors.
- Mandatory free medical treatment by all hospitals under Section 357C CrPC (Section 397 BNSS).
- Model rules regulating retail sale of acid across India.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Article 21, Acid Attacks, Victim Compensation, IPC 326A, CrPC 357B