Lily Thomas v. Union of India (2013)
Supreme Court of India · (2013) 7 SCC 653 · 2-Judge Bench
Summary
The Court struck down Section 8(4) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, which deferred the disqualification of sitting MPs/MLAs upon conviction until appeal. Sitting members stand disqualified under Section 8(1)–(3) immediately on conviction, like any other candidate.
Facts
- Petitions challenged the constitutionality of Section 8(4) RP Act, which protected sitting legislators from immediate disqualification upon conviction if they filed an appeal within three months.
- The challenge was rooted in equality and the purity of the legislative process in the face of criminalisation of politics.
Issues
- Whether Section 8(4) RP Act, saving sitting members from immediate disqualification on conviction, is constitutionally valid.
- Whether Parliament could classify sitting members differently from other convicted persons for disqualification purposes.
Provisions involved
- Constitution of India — Art. Article 102 — Disqualifications for membership (Parliament)
- Representation of the People Act, 1951 — s. Section 8 RP Act — Disqualification on conviction for certain offences
Reasoning
Invalid classification under Section 8(4)
The Court held that Section 8(4) created an artificial distinction between sitting members and other candidates/convicts and was beyond the constitutional scheme of disqualification under Articles 102 and 191.
Immediate disqualification on conviction
Once a sitting MP or MLA is convicted and sentenced in terms of Section 8(1)–(3), disqualification operates at once; continuation in office pending appeal is not saved by Section 8(4).
Decision
Section 8(4) RP Act was struck down. Sitting legislators are disqualified immediately upon conviction attracting Section 8(1)–(3). The judgment is central to criminalisation-of-politics jurisprudence.
Ratio decidendi
Parliament cannot defer the disqualification of sitting legislators upon conviction in a manner that undermines the constitutional disqualification scheme and equality before the law; Section 8(4) RP Act is void.
Exam points
- Section 8(4) RP Act struck down.
- Sitting MP/MLA disqualified immediately on conviction under Section 8(1)–(3).
- Articles 102 and 191 frame constitutional disqualification.
- Key case on criminalisation of politics.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Elections, Disqualification, Criminalisation of Politics