Lucknow Development Authority v. M.K. Gupta (1994)
Supreme Court of India · (1994) 1 SCC 243
Summary
The Supreme Court held that housing construction and allotment by a statutory development authority can constitute a service under the Consumer Protection Act and that deficiency in such service can attract consumer remedies.
Facts
- M.K. Gupta obtained a residential property through a scheme operated by the Lucknow Development Authority.
- Delay and deficiencies in the housing service led to proceedings under the Consumer Protection Act.
Issues
- Whether a statutory development authority providing housing is rendering a consumer service.
- Whether deficiency in that service can attract consumer compensation and accountability.
Provisions involved
- Consumer Protection Act, 1986 — s. Section 2(1)(o) — Service
- Consumer Protection Act, 1986 — s. Section 2(1)(g) — Deficiency
Reasoning
Service by public authorities
The statutory character of the provider does not by itself remove a housing activity performed for consideration from consumer protection where the statutory definition of service is satisfied.
Deficiency and effective remedy
Delay or deficient performance in a covered housing service can support consumer relief, including compensation within the statutory framework.
Decision
The Court rejected the attempt to place the housing service outside consumer jurisdiction merely because the provider was a statutory authority.
Ratio decidendi
Consumer legislation is applied to covered services according to its statutory definitions; public or statutory status alone does not create an immunity from consumer jurisdiction.
Exam points
- Service under the Consumer Protection Act.
- Housing by development authorities.
- Deficiency in service and compensation.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Consumer, Public Authority