State of Gujarat v. Mirzapur Moti Kureshi Kassab Jamat (2005)
Supreme Court of India · (2005) 8 SCC 534 · 7-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
Landmark 7-judge Constitution Bench judgment upholding a total ban on the slaughter of cows, bulls, and bullocks of all ages in Gujarat. Partially overruled the 5-judge bench in Quareshi-I (1958), holding that even aged and dry cattle produce valuable biogas, bio-fertilizer, and draught power, rendering total ban a reasonable restriction under Article 19(6) read with Article 48 and Article 51A(g).
Facts
- The Bombay Animal Preservation (Gujarat Amendment) Act, 1994 imposed a total ban on the slaughter of bulls and bullocks of any age in Gujarat.
- Butchers and meat traders challenged the amendment on the ground that in Mohd. Hanif Quareshi (1958), the Supreme Court had held that a total ban on the slaughter of bulls and bullocks above 16 years of age was unreasonable and violative of Article 19(1)(g).
- The Gujarat High Court struck down the legislation following Quareshi-I. The State of Gujarat appealed to the Supreme Court.
Issues
- Whether a total ban on the slaughter of bulls and bullocks of all ages violates the fundamental right to practice a trade under Article 19(1)(g).
- Can dynamic economic conditions and Directive Principles (Articles 48 and 51A) justify overruling earlier precedents on cattle preservation.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Dynamic interpretation of reasonable restrictions
Lahoti, C.J. held that reasonableness under Article 19(6) is not static. What was unreasonable in 1958 when Quareshi-I was decided may be entirely reasonable in 2005 due to environmental degradation, rising crude oil prices, and the necessity of organic bio-manure.
Ecological utility of aging cattle
The Court accepted scientific material showing that even post-milch and dry cattle continue to produce organic manure and biogas throughout their lifespan. A total ban on cattle slaughter is therefore in the genuine interest of the agrarian economy.
Decision
Appeals allowed. Judgment of the Gujarat High Court set aside. The Bombay Animal Preservation (Gujarat Amendment) Act, 1994 held constitutionally valid.
Ratio decidendi
A statutory prohibition on the slaughter of cattle, including bulls and bullocks of all ages, constitutes a reasonable restriction under Article 19(6) in the interest of the general public, harmonizing Fundamental Rights with Directive Principles (Article 48) and Fundamental Duties (Article 51A(g)) to support the agrarian and ecological economy.
Exam points
- 7-judge Constitution Bench decision on cattle slaughter and Article 19(1)(g).
- Overruled Quareshi-I on the invalidity of total ban on slaughter of aged bulls/bullocks.
- Harmonious integration of Fundamental Rights with Articles 48 and 51A(g).
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 19(1)(g), Article 48, DPSP, Fundamental Duties