Mithu v. State of Punjab (1983)
Supreme Court of India · (1983) 2 SCC 277 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
Historic 5-judge Constitution Bench judgment striking down Section 303 of the Indian Penal Code as unconstitutional, null and void. Section 303 mandated death penalty for any person committing murder while undergoing a life sentence. Held that stripping the judiciary of sentencing discretion and creating an irrational classification violates Articles 14 and 21.
Facts
- Mithu and several other life-convicts challenged the constitutional validity of Section 303 IPC.
- Section 303 provided: "Whoever, being under sentence of imprisonment for life, commits murder, shall be punished with death."
- Unlike Section 302 IPC (now Section 103(1) BNS), which provided life imprisonment or death, Section 303 left judges zero discretion, compelling the mandatory imposition of the death sentence upon conviction.
Issues
- Whether Section 303 IPC violates Article 14 by creating an arbitrary and unreasonable classification between persons committing murder while undergoing life imprisonment and others.
- Whether the deprivation of judicial sentencing discretion violates the guarantee of fair, just, and reasonable procedure under Article 21.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Arbitrary classification under Article 14
Chandrachud, C.J. held that Section 303 IPC creates an irrational distinction between murders committed by life convicts and murders committed by persons not under life sentence. A person on parole, or whose conviction is suspended, was mechanically subjected to the gallows without any rational basis.
Denial of judicial discretion violates Article 21
A law which deprives the court of the use of its wise and beneficent discretion to choose between life imprisonment and death penalty is harsh, unreasonable, and oppressive. Following Maneka Gandhi and Bachan Singh, procedure established by law must be just, fair, and reasonable.
Decision
Section 303 of the Indian Penal Code struck down as unconstitutional, null and void. All murders committed by life-convicts to be governed by Section 302 IPC (now Section 103 BNS).
Ratio decidendi
Section 303 IPC violates Articles 14 and 21 because it deprives the court of its judicial discretion to determine the appropriate sentence based on the circumstances of the offender and the crime. A mandatory death penalty denies the fundamental right to be heard on sentence under Section 235(2) CrPC.
Exam points
- Section 303 IPC struck down as violative of Articles 14 and 21.
- Mandatory capital punishment is wholly unconstitutional in India.
- Judges must retain discretion to consider mitigating circumstances under Bachan Singh doctrine.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, IPC, Section 303, Death Penalty, Article 14, Article 21