Mohd. Ahmed Khan v. Shah Bano Begum (1985)
Supreme Court of India · (1985) 2 SCC 556 · Five-Judge Constitution Bench · 1985-04-23
Summary
The Supreme Court held that the secular maintenance remedy under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure applied to a divorced Muslim woman who was unable to maintain herself, and explained that the provision was directed to preventing destitution and vagrancy.
Facts
- Shah Bano, a divorced Muslim woman, sought maintenance under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure after her former husband ceased supporting her.
- The dispute reached the Supreme Court after proceedings concerning the extent of the husband’s maintenance obligation.
- The Court examined Section 125 as a secular remedy designed to prevent destitution and vagrancy.
Issues
- Whether a divorced Muslim woman unable to maintain herself could invoke Section 125 CrPC.
- Whether the secular maintenance remedy was displaced by the personal law position asserted by the husband.
- What was the relationship between the statutory maintenance remedy and personal-law obligations.
Reasoning
Secular character of Section 125
The Court treated Section 125 as a secular social-justice provision applicable irrespective of the personal law of the parties.
Purpose of maintenance
The provision was designed to prevent destitution and vagrancy by requiring maintenance in the statutory circumstances.
Interaction with personal law
The Court distinguished the statutory remedy from the separate question of personal-law obligations and applied the statutory conditions governing Section 125.
Decision
The Supreme Court upheld the maintenance relief under Section 125 CrPC and rejected the contention that the secular statutory remedy was unavailable merely because the parties were governed by Muslim personal law.
Ratio decidendi
Section 125 CrPC is a secular social-justice measure intended to prevent destitution and vagrancy. Its availability is not defeated merely by the personal law applicable to the parties.
Exam points
- Section 125 CrPC is a secular maintenance remedy.
- The statutory inquiry focuses on inability to maintain oneself and the conditions of Section 125.
- The case is a leading authority on maintenance of divorced Muslim women under the pre-1986 statutory framework.
Tags: family-law, maintenance, section-125-crpc, muslim-women