Mohini Jain v. State of Karnataka (1992)
Supreme Court of India · (1992) 3 SCC 666 · 2-Judge Bench
Summary
The Court held that the right to education is concomitant of the fundamental rights enshrined in Part III, and that charging capitation fee for admission to educational institutions is arbitrary and violative of Article 14. The judgment was an important precursor to Unni Krishnan and later Article 21A.
Facts
- A student challenged the demand of a large capitation fee as a condition for admission to a private medical college in Karnataka.
- The petition raised whether the State could permit commercialisation of education through capitation.
Issues
- Whether the right to education is part of the fundamental rights framework.
- Whether capitation-fee based admission is constitutional.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Education and fundamental rights
The Court treated the right to education as flowing from the dignity and opportunity structure of Part III, rejecting a purely commercial model of professional education.
Capitation as arbitrariness
Demanding capitation fee as a price of admission was held to be arbitrary and discriminatory, favouring the rich over the meritorious poor.
Decision
Capitation fee based admissions were condemned. The decision is read with Unni Krishnan (1993) and later T.M.A. Pai on private institutional autonomy.
Ratio decidendi
Commercialisation of education through capitation fees violates equality and is inconsistent with the constitutional commitment to education as part of a life of dignity.
Exam points
- Capitation fee held unconstitutional.
- Education linked to Part III / dignity.
- Read with Unni Krishnan and Article 21A trajectory.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Education, Article 21, Capitation