Motilal Padampat Sugar Mills Co. Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh (1979)
Supreme Court of India · (1979) 2 SCC 409 · 2-Judge Bench
Summary
Seminal Supreme Court precedent establishing the modern doctrine of Promissory Estoppel against the Government in India. Held that where the Government makes a clear and unequivocal representation intending to create legal relations and a citizen acts upon it to his detriment, the Government is bound by the promise and cannot arbitrarily resile from it, except by establishing a superior public interest.
Facts
- The State of Uttar Pradesh announced in newspaper advertisements and official statements that new industrial units set up in the State would be granted exemption from sales tax for a period of three years under the U.P. Sales Tax Act.
- Relying on this explicit representation, Motilal Padampat Sugar Mills Co. Ltd. established a vanaspati manufacturing plant at Kanpur, borrowing substantial loans from financial institutions.
- The company confirmed the exemption promise in official correspondence with the Chief Secretary and the Director of Industries.
- Later, when the factory was near completion, the State Government changed its policy and refused to grant the promised sales tax exemption.
- The company filed a writ petition before the Allahabad High Court, which was dismissed.
- The company appealed to the Supreme Court.
Issues
- Whether the doctrine of promissory estoppel can be invoked against the Government to enforce an executive promise in the absence of a formal contract under Article 299.
- Whether promissory estoppel requires proof of actual financial damage or merely that the promisee altered his position in reliance upon the promise.
- What are the exceptions to the doctrine of promissory estoppel when public interest is pleaded by the State.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Birth of promissory estoppel as an independent cause of action
Bhagwati, J. held that promissory estoppel is an equitable principle evolved to prevent injustice. It is not constrained by traditional contract law rules of consideration or Article 299 formal requirements. It can form the basis of a cause of action (a sword and not merely a shield) where a party has altered his position relying upon an executive representation.
Burden on the State to demonstrate superior public interest
The Government cannot escape its promise on a mere claim of change of policy. To defeat promissory estoppel, the Government must place facts before the court showing that an overriding public interest arose which supervenes the equity in favor of the citizen. No such public interest was proved by the State of U.P.
Decision
Appeal allowed. The State Government was directed to grant sales tax exemption to the appellant company for the promised three-year period. Promissory estoppel was held enforceable against the Government.
Ratio decidendi
The doctrine of promissory estoppel is not limited to contract law and does not require formal compliance with Article 299. Where the Government makes a clear and unequivocal promise knowing that it would be acted upon, and the promisee alters his position in reliance upon it, equity will bind the Government. The Government can resile from the promise only by demonstrating that a superior public interest justifies the change of policy.
Exam points
- Leading authority on the Doctrine of Promissory Estoppel in Indian administrative law.
- Established that promissory estoppel can be a sword (cause of action) and not merely a shield.
- Clarified that overriding public interest is the only valid defense for the State to resile from its promise.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Administrative Law, Promissory Estoppel, Contract, Evidence, Article 14