Nabam Rebia & Bamang Felix v. Deputy Speaker, Arunachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly (2016)
Supreme Court of India · (2016) 8 SCC 1 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
The Court held that the Governor cannot summon, prorogue, or dissolve the House contrary to the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers so long as the government enjoys confidence; and that a Speaker should not decide disqualification petitions under the Tenth Schedule while a motion for the Speaker’s own removal is pending.
Facts
- Political turmoil in Arunachal Pradesh involved the Governor’s messages and directions regarding Assembly sessions and the Speaker’s handling of disqualification proceedings.
- The status of the Chief Minister’s government, the role of the Governor under Articles 163 and 174, and the Speaker’s impartiality in defection cases were in issue.
Issues
- Whether the Governor can independently summon the Assembly or fix its agenda contrary to the Council of Ministers’ advice when the government has not lost confidence.
- Whether the Speaker can decide Tenth Schedule disqualifications while facing a pending removal motion.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Governor and aid and advice
The Court held that so long as the Council of Ministers enjoys the confidence of the House, the Governor must act on its aid and advice in matters of summoning and related Assembly business, save where the Constitution expressly confers discretion.
Speaker and pending removal motion
A Speaker should not proceed with Tenth Schedule disqualification proceedings when a notice of resolution for the Speaker’s removal is pending, to protect impartiality and constitutional morality.
Decision
The Court set aside the unconstitutional course of action in the Arunachal crisis and restored constitutional principles governing the Governor–Council of Ministers relationship and the Speaker’s role. The judgment is frequently cited with Bommai on floor tests and federal norms.
Ratio decidendi
Responsible government at the State level requires that the Governor act on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers enjoying confidence; the Speaker’s adjudicatory role under the Tenth Schedule is incompatible with deciding disqualifications while the Speaker’s own removal motion is pending.
Exam points
- Governor bound by aid and advice when ministry has confidence.
- Speaker should not hear Tenth Schedule cases while removal motion pending.
- Arunachal Pradesh Assembly crisis factual matrix.
- Pair with Bommai and Kihoto Hollohan in answers.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Governor, Federalism, Speaker, Article 174