Nandini Satpathy v. P.L. Dani (1978)
Supreme Court of India · (1978) 2 SCC 424 · 3-Judge Bench
Summary
Landmark 3-judge bench ruling holding that the constitutional protection against self-incrimination under Article 20(3) extends to police interrogations under Section 161 CrPC (s. 180 BNSS). The phrase "accused of any offence" covers suspects under investigative interrogation, shielding them from compulsory self-incriminating answers.
Facts
- Nandini Satpathy, former Chief Minister of Orissa, was directed to appear before the Deputy Superintendent of Police (Vigilance) in connection with an investigation into disproportionate assets registered under the Prevention of Corruption Act.
- During police interrogation, she was served with a lengthy written questionnaire comprising several detailed questions regarding her income, political financing, and property acquisitions.
- She refused to answer questions that she asserted were designed to incriminate her in criminal charges.
- The investigating officer lodged a complaint against her before the Magistrate under Section 179 IPC (refusing to answer public servant authorized to question).
- The Magistrate took cognizance and issued process, which she challenged before the High Court and subsequently the Supreme Court under Article 20(3) and Section 161(2) CrPC.
Issues
- Whether the constitutional guarantee against self-incrimination under Article 20(3) applies to police interrogation during investigation under Section 161 CrPC before a formal complaint or charge-sheet is filed.
- Whether an accused or suspect is entitled to remain silent to questions that have a tendency to expose them to a criminal charge or forfeiture.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Scope of Article 20(3) during police interrogation
Krishna Iyer, J. held that the phrase "accused of any offence" in Article 20(3) is not confined to a person already formally arraigned before a Magistrate; it extends to suspects examined by the police under Section 161 CrPC if the questions tend to elicit incriminating disclosures. To limit Article 20(3) to trials would render the protection illusory.
Right to silence and tendency to expose to criminal charge
Section 161(2) CrPC mirrors the constitutional privilege by expressly exempting answers having a tendency to expose the person to a criminal charge or penalty. A witness or suspect is entitled to remain silent in the face of incriminating questions without attracting penal sanction under Section 179 IPC.
Decision
Prosecution under Section 179 IPC quashed. The Supreme Court held that Article 20(3) applies to suspects subjected to police questioning under Section 161(2) CrPC. The right to remain silent shields any question whose answer has a reasonable tendency to expose the person to criminal liability.
Ratio decidendi
The protection of Article 20(3) extends to police interrogation under Section 161 CrPC. Section 161(2) CrPC embodies the constitutional privilege by exempting answers that have a tendency to expose the person to a criminal charge. The phrase "accused of any offence" embraces a suspect against whom an investigation is directed. While an accused has no right to absolute silence to non-incriminating administrative details, compulsory extraction of self-incriminatory statements through psychological or physical pressure violates Article 20(3).
Exam points
- Defines the interface between Section 161(2) CrPC (s. 180(2) BNSS) and Article 20(3).
- Clarifies that "accused" under Art. 20(3) extends to suspects under police interrogation.
- Advocates lawyer presence during interrogation to eliminate custodial coercion.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, BNSS, CrPC, Constitution, Article 20, Self-Incrimination, Right to Silence