Narmada Bachao Andolan v. Union of India (2000)

Supreme Court of India · (2000) 10 SCC 664 · 3-Judge Bench

Summary

Landmark 3-judge bench ruling permitting the continuation of construction of the Sardar Sarovar Dam on the Narmada River up to height clearances cleared by the Narmada Water Disputes Tribunal. Held that large dams are essential for supplying drinking water, irrigation, and green hydroelectric power to drought-prone regions, and balanced environmental concerns through comprehensive, court-monitored Relief and Rehabilitation (R&R) packages.

Facts

  • The Sardar Sarovar Project, a multi-purpose mega-dam on the Narmada River, was planned to supply drinking water to parched areas of Gujarat and Rajasthan and generate power for Madhya Pradesh.
  • Social activist Medha Patkar and the Narmada Bachao Andolan (NBA) filed a PIL under Article 32 contending that raising the dam height would submerge hundreds of villages, displace tribal communities without rehabilitation, and destroy pristine forest ecosystems.
  • In 1995, the Supreme Court halted construction pending comprehensive appraisal of relief and environmental clearance.

Issues

  • Can the judiciary sit in appeal over executive policy decisions to construct mega development dams.
  • How to balance the right to life under Article 21 of displaced tribals against the right to life and water of millions living in arid, drought-stricken regions.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Judicial restraint in mega developmental projects

Kirpal, J. held that when a policy decision to construct a multi-purpose dam is taken after extensive technical studies, the court cannot sit as an appellate environmental authority. Public interest litigation cannot be used to halt mega infrastructure projects unless gross illegality is established.

Sustainable development and the right to water

The Court held that the right to water is part of the right to life under Article 21. Confining millions in drought zones to misery cannot be justified. Construction was permitted to proceed up to 90 meters, and subsequently stage-by-stage up to 138.68 meters, subject to strict compliance with rehabilitation conditions for displaced persons.

Decision

Writ petition dismissed by 2:1 majority (Bharucha, J. dissenting on initial environmental clearance). Construction of the Sardar Sarovar Dam permitted under ongoing Grievance Redressal Authority supervision.

Ratio decidendi

In environmental and developmental jurisprudence under Article 21, courts must apply the principle of sustainable development to harmonize ecological concerns with the legitimate necessity for infrastructure. When a mega-project provides drinking water and irrigation to millions, construction cannot be halted if adequate rehabilitation and resettlement packages are enforced for displaced persons.

Exam points

  • Leading judgment on balancing economic development and environmental protection.
  • Scope of judicial review over policy decisions in infrastructure projects.
  • Enforceability of Relief and Rehabilitation (R&R) packages under Article 21.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Environment, Article 21, Sustainable Development, Narmada Dam, Rehabilitation

All judgments