State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu (Parliament Attack Case) (2005)

Supreme Court of India · (2005) 11 SCC 600 · 2-Judge Bench

Summary

The Supreme Court adjudicated the historic criminal appeals arising from the 13 December 2001 terrorist attack on the Parliament of India. The Court laid down vital principles on criminal conspiracy under Section 120B IPC and Section 10 of the Evidence Act (now Section 8 BSA), the admissibility of intercepted telephone call records, and standards for capital punishment under Section 121 IPC (waging war against the Government of India).

Facts

  • On 13 December 2001, five heavily armed terrorists entered the Parliament House complex in a car bearing fake official decals and opened fire, killing eight security personnel and a gardener before being neutralized.
  • Special Cell police arrested Mohd. Afzal Guru, Shaukat Hussain Guru, S.A.R. Geelani, and Navjot Sandhu (Afsan Guru), charging them with conspiracy under POTA, Section 121, 302, and 120B IPC.
  • The prosecution relied heavily on call detail records (CDRs), mobile phone intercepts, confessions under POTA, and recoveries.
  • The trial court convicted all four, sentencing three to death. The High Court acquitted Geelani and Navjot Sandhu while confirming the death sentences of Afzal Guru and Shaukat Hussain.

Issues

  • What is the scope and evidentiary threshold of Section 10 of the Evidence Act regarding statements of co-conspirators.
  • Whether the circumstantial evidence established Afzal Guru’s active conspiratorial role in the attack.
  • Whether intercepted telephone conversations and call printouts were admissible in evidence.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Interpretation of Section 10 Evidence Act (Conspiracy)

Venkatarama Reddi, J. held that Section 10 introduces the agency doctrine in conspiracy. Anything said, done, or written by any conspirator in reference to their common intention is admissible against all. However, there must first be prima facie evidence of agreement, and statements made after the conspiracy had terminated are not admissible under Section 10.

Role of Afzal Guru and Capital Sentence

The Court held that the attack on Parliament was an attack on the sovereignty of India, amounting to waging war under Section 121 IPC. The circumstantial evidence proved beyond reasonable doubt that Afzal Guru was the central linchpin of the conspiracy who harboured the terrorists and procured logistical equipment. His death sentence was confirmed as falling within the rarest of rare cases.

Decision

Death sentence of Mohd. Afzal Guru confirmed under Section 121 IPC / Section 302 IPC; Shaukat Hussain’s sentence commuted to 10 years imprisonment; acquittals of Geelani and Navjot Sandhu upheld.

Ratio decidendi

To attract Section 10 Evidence Act, there must be independent prima facie proof of a common conspiratorial intention; once established, acts of one conspirator in furtherance of the common design bind all conspirators.

Exam points

  • Benchmark judgment on Section 10 Evidence Act (BSA Section 8) and agency in conspiracy.
  • Interpretation of "waging war against the Government of India" under Section 121 IPC.
  • Note: Its ruling on Section 65B electronic evidence was later overruled in Anvar P.V. (2014).

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, BSA, Evidence Act 10, BSA 8, Conspiracy, Parliament Attack, Section 120B IPC

All judgments